
| NateEdits vs. MashupGFX vs. Wrestle Maniak | |
|---|---|
| Tweet Topic Started: Jan 6 2018, 06:50 PM (258 Views) | |
| -EXPLICIT- | Jan 6 2018, 06:50 PM Post #1 |
|
1st BFC Leader/Owner of BFC
|
NateEdits vs. MashupGFX vs. Wrestle Maniak Voting ends January 21 NateEdits MashupGFX Wrestle Maniak Edited by LastBreath, Jan 7 2018, 02:23 AM.
|
![]() |
|
| GoldenSkulls | Jan 7 2018, 05:09 AM Post #2 |
|
Creator of bfc logo. Best human being on this planet. Future BFC World Champ and Tag Champ.
|
NateEdits: Idk where to start, but dude…. This is awesome. Pacing was great, and while the syncing was a bit off sometimes, I think most of the times it was good. The nameplate was ehh….. but I liked how it matching with the fast pace of the song and how it was action from the start. Nothing else to say, but this was great, maybe even enough to get into a BFC World Championship match 👀 MashupGFX: Pretty enjoyable video, but the slow motion ruined the pacing in some parts like 0:25 where the song was very fast paced. Nameplate was beast and the cc was too, however I didn’t like the cookie cutter. You should’ve feathered it more and MAYBE added some effects of that make the colour match with the CC. Be in mind though that sometimes matching CC and Cookie Cutter can be bad, hence why I said maybe. Overall pacing and sync is what you need to work on, along with some work on your clip selection. You have the presentation pretty perfect (did ya see that alliteration? 😏) though. Wrestle Maniak: First, just wanna say that I loved the effects and cc, and how you kept the cookie cutter short, however I believe the transitions in this did not fit, along with the shots like 1:24 where Jason isn’t even the main subject and Titus Worldwide and the ref take most of the screen but in that 1:21 part, I liked the stuff with Jason raising his hands, pretty smooth. One last feedback; I know people say this to you a lot and you say ‘its your style of trons’ but when you end the clips too early, the sync completely falls off and it ends up looking bad. I think this is my biggest feedback for you, because if you fixed it, your trons would be 10x better. Also, pretty long loop, good job.So my vote for this one is NateEdits, and Mashup and Maniak’s trons were good, but Nate’s were on another level. |
![]() |
|
| Wrestle Maniak | Jan 7 2018, 04:39 PM Post #3 |
|
That's golden Feedback GoldenSkullsWWE |
![]() |
|
| DBF | Jan 7 2018, 06:14 PM Post #4 |
|
NateEdits: First of all, man..... This tron is probably your best. The pacing was great and so was the sync. And I agree GoldenSkulls, even though the sync was a bit off in some parts, it still managed to do well in other parts of the tron. The nameplate was pretty good, but I loved how the pace was going well with the song. Once again, fantastic job Nate. MashupGFX: This was really good. The nameplate was very well done, also the cc. To he honest, I didn't like the cookie cutter, it kind of ruins the cc. But overall, you did an amazing job. The sync was a bit off too but it was still 👍. Wrestle Maniak: This is pretty good. I love the cc and the effects on this. The sync was decent too. However, the nameplate, didn't match the cc you used. Also I told you this before and I know that you heard this a million times, don't end the clips too early, it sort of ruins the tron. This feed back I gave you is the one you really need to work on bro. The clips are long which I like 👍 good job on that. Overall, you did decent job. Fix the problem where you end the clips too early, and you will do better in your future trons. ![]() Overall, the three of you guys did a fantastic job, however my vote for this one is............... *Drum Roll*...... NateEdits. |
![]() |
|
| Broken Black | Jan 8 2018, 09:44 AM Post #5 |
|
The CC of NateEdits was not really good, it was just some kind of glow effect and his Nameplate was pretty boring as well. His Sync was pretty good and his clip-selection also was wonderful. He had some good Twixtor, but not always. The Pacing also was very good. Pretty good Titantron. The Nameplate of MGFX was just too sweet! At the Burn It Down Part fire could have been added, even if it would be just a Transition. His Color Correction was alright, and his sync was good. The Noise Effect at the Side cut of at random sections during the Titantrons, which was pretty weird. His Clip Selection was alright and over all his Titantron was pretty solid. Wrestle Maniak, the Nameplate was pretty boring, a bit of camera movement would have helped. The Cookie Cutter effect didn't really fit Jason Jordan. The sync was good, but the clips have been cut off to fast. Winner: NateEdits |
![]() |
|
| LastBreath | Jan 11 2018, 06:04 PM Post #6 |
|
Daddy/BFC Owner
|
NateEdits: Freakin' beauty! This is incredible. I love the clip selection, syncing, pacing, and effects. The nameplate could use a little work, but other than that, I love everything about it ![]() MashupGFX: I peed a little. I love Rollins, and I love this tron. The nameplate was the strong point in this video. The effects and border were pretty cool. Overall nice tron 👍 Wrestle Maniak: Man... pretty nice nameplate. The effects didn't really match the nameplate at all tbh. Tron could use a some work overall, but a decent attempt ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ |
![]() |
|
| WWEACProductions | Jan 11 2018, 06:07 PM Post #7 |
|
NateEdits: Bro, the titantron was fricken awesome. I love the pacing and how it matches the speed of the song. I also love the filter you added into it. Not much other than it was awesome. MashupGFX: Like the titantron. I'm not sure if it's just me, correct me anyone if I'm wrong, but it seems like the filter changes sometimes from a tint green/yellow to more of a gold color. I like the nameplate, the only thing I would fix is the nameplate goes into frame kinda slow when the song is pretty fast. Wrestle Maniak: The titantron was decent. However, I did not like the brightness that is used with the filter in the video. The clips seem to long at certain points and lastly, the nameplate should've had some movement to it instead of just staying there in one spot. Winner: NateEdits |
![]() |
|
| 1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous) | |
| « Previous Topic · New Year's Bash Voting Thread · Next Topic » |
| Track Topic · E-mail Topic |
2:17 PM Jul 11
|

Theme by James... of the ZBTZ and themeszetaboards.com






One last feedback; I know people say this to you a lot and you say ‘its your style of trons’ but when you end the clips too early, the sync completely falls off and it ends up looking bad. I think this is my biggest feedback for you, because if you fixed it, your trons would be 10x better. Also, pretty long loop, good job.

2:17 PM Jul 11