Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Add Reply
Amendment Proposal- Abolishing the Courts; A self repealing amendment to temporarily abolish the court system in favor a tribunal
Topic Started: Jan 5 2018, 10:11 AM (198 Views)
Momo
Member Avatar
Da Party
It in fact practically gives no power to anybody. The power of understanding and acting on the law is given to all officials, like it was before, the power to check any other official is also returned to how it was before. Like I literally just said, it's always been the MoDA's job to oversee domestic affairs. It should remain the MoDA's job to oversee any and all domestic affairs, which would include knowing and understanding our laws and regulations.
The Party, Long retired President of Conch Kingdom
Head of TOP, Proud member of the Democratic Union of Conch Kingdom
No political party will ever be nearly as good as DUCK, for obvious reasons
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
New Jaedonstan
Member Avatar
Prince of Spies
So one person should be left in charge of saying how the law should be interpreted.
-Official Communication of New Jaedonstan
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Momo
Member Avatar
Da Party
If questioned, yes. Exactly how often is our law unclear though?
The Party, Long retired President of Conch Kingdom
Head of TOP, Proud member of the Democratic Union of Conch Kingdom
No political party will ever be nearly as good as DUCK, for obvious reasons
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
New Jaedonstan
Member Avatar
Prince of Spies
Often enough to make having only one person interpreting it a bad idea.
-Official Communication of New Jaedonstan
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Momo
Member Avatar
Da Party
I would argue never. Our law is rather fairly clear 100% of the time. It literally says "you cannot do this this and this and here's what happens to you if you do"
The Party, Long retired President of Conch Kingdom
Head of TOP, Proud member of the Democratic Union of Conch Kingdom
No political party will ever be nearly as good as DUCK, for obvious reasons
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
New Jaedonstan
Member Avatar
Prince of Spies
There have been several times where Tulov has asked the justices if something is legal or not and it will happen again.
-Official Communication of New Jaedonstan
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Momo
Member Avatar
Da Party
What sort of thing does he ask about? And please, please please please point out one line that isn't clear
The Party, Long retired President of Conch Kingdom
Head of TOP, Proud member of the Democratic Union of Conch Kingdom
No political party will ever be nearly as good as DUCK, for obvious reasons
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
New Jaedonstan
Member Avatar
Prince of Spies
Asked about the legality of appointing temporary officers, passwording the region, and about instantly banjecting spammers. I didin't say the law wasn't clear, I'm just saying it doesn't cover everything.
-Official Communication of New Jaedonstan
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Momo
Member Avatar
Da Party
New Jaedonstan
Jan 16 2018, 11:59 AM
Asked about the legality of appointing temporary officers, passwording the region, and about instantly banjecting spammers. I didin't say the law wasn't clear, I'm just saying it doesn't cover everything.
If the law doesn't cover it, then how would anyone know the legality of it? If it doesn't cover it, the answer is either "doesn't say you can" or "doesn't say you can't". Interpreting the law isn't making up answers for things it doesn't cover.
The Party, Long retired President of Conch Kingdom
Head of TOP, Proud member of the Democratic Union of Conch Kingdom
No political party will ever be nearly as good as DUCK, for obvious reasons
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
New Jaedonstan
Member Avatar
Prince of Spies
Regardless, giving the power to answer that question to one person is unsafe.
-Official Communication of New Jaedonstan
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · Regional Discussion · Next Topic »
Add Reply