Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Locked Topic
Day 1 - Darkness Falls
Topic Started: Sep 28 2016, 12:00 AM (6,826 Views)
Funkfreed
Member Avatar

Ohm
Sep 28 2016, 09:48 AM
Keimi
Sep 28 2016, 12:28 AM
Keimi waves hand frantically

Oh oh, me me!
Do any of you think the Mafia will try to play off their scummy behavior as simple role play? It's easy to do in this format. I say we shouldn't stand for it! Harrumph!
Funkfreed , please answer this question aswell as the other one I asked.

Thats why i suspected nero
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Porsche
Member Avatar

Sorry to be late friends! This game took off faster than I expected.
Three votes already... those votes were all cast rather hastily, but they seemed to be more than just joke votes. Well, no harm done as long as no actual wagons form.

The biggest question is: should we lynch today? I'd say no. The chance of us killing one of our own is too high, like Laki calculated. BUT if a conflict develops, or someone is acting very scummy, or slips up, then I think a lynch could be useful. But we shouldn't lynch just to lynch, and not without in-depth discussion first.

The presence of a Third Party is possible with this many people... but we don't have anything to go on that there would be one for now. So I wouldn't put too much thought into that. The priority is finding the Mafia, because we at least know they exist.

I took some notes on people's behaviour. We have a few avid roleplayers, like Keimi, Salome and Funkfreed... for Day 1 it's nothing unusual, and nothing to worry about as long as they get serious when it counts imho.
Then there's Laki, who seems to be taking the lead, and whom some players trust a little too easily... We should be careful with players guiding the Town.
The mafia usually kind of stays in the background, especially at the start of the game, but it also happens quite often that at least 1 mafia member is very active and takes the lead. Usually that'll be an experienced player, but I guess we can't be sure of that on this board.

Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Ohm
Member Avatar

Funkfreed
Sep 28 2016, 09:54 AM
Ohm
Sep 28 2016, 09:48 AM
Keimi
Sep 28 2016, 12:28 AM
Keimi waves hand frantically

Oh oh, me me!
Do any of you think the Mafia will try to play off their scummy behavior as simple role play? It's easy to do in this format. I say we shouldn't stand for it! Harrumph!
Funkfreed , please answer this question aswell as the other one I asked.

Thats why i suspected nero
Could you elaborate on that?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Funkfreed
Member Avatar

He acts and talks scummy in my view
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Funkfreed
Member Avatar

Going Merry do you have anything to say ?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Dorry
Member Avatar
Giant-Term Memory Loss
The mafia would have to be extremely daring to put himself into a limelight prosecutor role first. They would more likely settle into a role behind them, to avert suspiscion.

Does Ohm have something to gain? Perhaps we should lynch him!
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Boa Sandersonia
Member Avatar

Funkfreed
Sep 28 2016, 07:27 AM
Ruuuuuu
(I wanna lynch nero he is scummy for me
But some feeling stops me )

What's stopping you? Throwing vague suspicions then taking it back, that sounds like fake scumhunting. You didn't give a reason for way he was scummy or why you're not sure. The more I think about it the more I don't like it.

Toto
Sep 28 2016, 06:45 AM
Johnny
Sep 28 2016, 02:32 AM
Well you should have faith in Laki at least.
Oh, dear. There are so many things wrong with this statement. If taken at face value, you are telling me already to trust someone. This is problematic, even if only for the possibility of the misinterpretation. But clearly this is not what you mean. You are being clever. Unfortunately, it means you are outing someone's identity. Oh, how that goes against the spirit of this game, and the decision to move off-forum. Moreover, you state it with such confidence. Why should I not suspect that perhaps your certainty comes from being a partner in crime of this player, and you have shared your identities amongst yourselves? Oh, this is too much for this old man to bear.

Vote Lynch: Johnny

When you're Mafia you know who's who. You can protect your friends or follow a townie you feel could lead. Waiting on Johnny to explain himself cause having faith in anyone on day one isn't something I'd do.

Funkfreed
Sep 28 2016, 08:57 AM
Ruuu
(To explain myself i just wanna keep talking untill something happens that we can use
And also there is another reason that i talk alot i can tell it in day 4 or 5)

Wow. So, we should keep you alive until then? That's a heck of a card you pulled. You're either scum trying to stay alive putting you on Powered Townies radar or you have a power and that puts you on the Mafia radar.

Why out yourself like that?

Ohm
Sep 28 2016, 09:02 AM
Funkfreed
Sep 28 2016, 08:52 AM
Ruuu
(Oh well i deserved that)
Is that seriously all you are going to say? You are not helping your case here. How about you answer some questions:

1) the role playing question , give me a clear reply
2) We don't seem to have any information about how many mafia there are . How do you think it might be split up? Do you think there is a third party?
3) Anyone's behavior that seems weird to you? Something that caught your eye?

Other people are also free to answer these questions . I'll answer these questions myself after I have heard Funkfreed's answers .

1. My first comment is the only roleplay I'll do. No excuses for me.
2. Day 2 will tell us more if more than one player dies. With no info I'm guessing their will be from a Meta level. Our host trying to keep thing interesting.
3. Johnny and Funkfreed.

Porsche
Sep 28 2016, 10:54 AM

The mafia usually kind of stays in the background, especially at the start of the game, but it also happens quite often that at least 1 mafia member is very active and takes the lead. Usually that'll be an experienced player, but I guess we can't be sure of that on this board.

The forum doesn't matter. The Mafia will pick varied Posting Roles. They would be foolish not to.



Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Nero
Member Avatar
I AM WEASEL
Shaoshaoshaoshaoshao~ the elephant does speak!

I have been asking questions and pressing for answers and Im the scummy one, thats fine-shao. What disturbs me more is that Funkfreed finds reading through the thread arduous when that is what every player should be doing to corroborate people's thoughts. Now he opens his trunk and mentions the possibility of a third party that, granted is possible, we have no real knowledge of one existing and is distracting us from how just "there" the elephant/sword has been here.

To be fair, there are others much more silent than he has been, but the fact that he has been here and just has been giving short rp lines with no substantive content is really worse. I said before, rp is not an excuse for active inactivity.

unvote

vote lynch: Funkfreed

Feel free to put that pressure vote down, I welcome it-shao.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Dorry
Member Avatar
Giant-Term Memory Loss
Nero
Sep 28 2016, 02:00 PM
vote lynch: Funkfreed
I don't think your boss would be happy with you, gegyagyagya
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Merry

@Funkfreed: You can call me Merry. I feel like I picked the wrong avatar but that's ok. I'm the Merry I want to be~

The chance of there being a lynching on Day 1 is very low. Not only is the risk to Town too high because there's nothing much to go off of and Town makes up the majority of players, but it will most likely give Scum a nice head start. Shooting ourselves in the foot I believe is the appropiate saying.

Coming off of the unlikely situation where a lynch is achieved on Day 1 and the high probability of the victim being Town the only pro from that situation is the gaining of information from who is lynched.

Also @Porsche: It's my experience that Mafia usually don't lay low because of all the talk about lynching inactives. Look at this very Day. I'm more concerned about...well, honestly I'm concerned about everyone, but more to the point I'm concerned about the active players only trying to appear helpful to Town.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · The Dungeon · Next Topic »
Locked Topic