Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Locked Topic
Day 1 - Darkness Falls
Topic Started: Sep 28 2016, 12:00 AM (6,812 Views)
Haredas
Member Avatar

going to sleep for real now.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Elizabello II
Member Avatar

I understand your concern. I just find the concept of a fool vastly annoying. At least, all other players have a general motivation to stay alive which creates a common ground for the game and acceptable behaviors. So, I tend to ignore fools in my approach.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Johnny
Member Avatar
Robert Townie Jr.
A fool wins if he/she is lynched.

Not the most common role, but in a 19 player game, with bananas... anything is possible
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Elizabello II
Member Avatar

Aw, so many posts. That was in reply to Johnny
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Johnny
Member Avatar
Robert Townie Jr.
And my post was to Haredas.

Elizabellio II
 

I understand your concern. I just find the concept of a fool vastly annoying. At least, all other players have a general motivation to stay alive which creates a common ground for the game and acceptable behaviors. So, I tend to ignore fools in my approach.


Fair enough.

But you can see why I suspect Brulee is up to.... something..
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Elizabello II
Member Avatar

Johnny
Sep 29 2016, 03:12 AM
And my post was to Haredas.

Elizabellio II
 

I understand your concern. I just find the concept of a fool vastly annoying. At least, all other players have a general motivation to stay alive which creates a common ground for the game and acceptable behaviors. So, I tend to ignore fools in my approach.


Fair enough.

But you can see why I suspect Brulee is up to.... something..
I do
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Aphelandra
Member Avatar
All I wanna be is the one who gets to see a giant woman
I have an issue with Toto, and his vote on Johnny.
Why have you not removed the vote now that Johnny's tried to explain himself? What benefit would Johnny have in revealing the identity of another person that makes him a possible target? You raised genuine suspicions of people, but Johnny is more of a threat because he cracks jokes? You really are old.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Toto
Member Avatar
A Hole New World
I didn't immediately remove my vote because Johnny's response was less than satisfactory. We still have 20 hours left. I am waiting for others to post again (and answer questions), as well as see if the no-shows wander in. After that, when I'm good and ready, I'll move my vote. That's how this old desert man rolls.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Laki
Member Avatar

Funkfreed
 
Ruuu
(To explain myself i just wanna keep talking untill something happens that we can use
And also there is another reason that i talk alot i can tell it in day 4 or 5)
Funkfreed
Sep 28 2016, 08:00 PM
Oh i didnt think that can be role claim at that moment
I meant was gonna explain the way i play mafia but well
If you want to "explain the way you play Mafia" or whatever, or at least explain what you meant by the previous post (which I included above this quote), why do you need to wait until Day 4 or 5 to do that? Why wouldn't you just tell us now to clear up the confusion? You phrasing it that way has raised a lot of eyebrows because it sounds like role-claiming (whether you meant it to or not), and you haven't done much to try to clarify.
Merry
Sep 29 2016, 02:07 AM
"QUESTION FOR EVERYBODY: How does you feel about lynching an inactive player on Day 1. Even if you answered this question before I'd appreciate it if you'd reiterate. As of now, as far as I know, Inazuma is the only player that has not posted yet on Day 1 but we still have a good number of hours left before the end of the Day. Do you think it's beneficial for Town to lynch an inactive player now or give them a chance to come on Day 2? Why?"

To answer my own question I think it's a bad idea to lynch Inazuma on Day 1 assuming the player stays inactive until the end of the Day. I don't think a Mafia member will purposely play the inactive game for the risks it carries. There are too many outside reasons a fellow Townie might not log in on the first Day and Town is strongest in numbers. We need numbers. To most likely give Mafia a headstart of 2 kills based on nothing but inactivity is faulty. On Day 2 of complete inactivity though ....that is a different matter as we gave that player a large enough chance to come on.
Here, I'll just quote what I said before for reference, since my opinion on the issue has not changed.
Laki
Sep 28 2016, 02:04 AM
If we have a missing player, then I'm with Johnny that that's much more of a hindrance for the Town than the Mafia. Sometimes in the past, the Mafia has killed the inactive to go for a "safe" kill and/or mess with us, but counting on them to do so would not be wise, and there's no time like the present, when we're still trying to get a read on those who are here, to weed out players like that. We're not going to want to have to waste a lynch on an inactive player later down the line when we actually do have real suspicions of other people.
Quite frankly, waiting until Day 2 before we consider Inazuma's inactivity unacceptable is too long. Hell, I already think it's unacceptable. Especially since I saw him online earlier today, so if he was having some kind of personal problems, he could have at least said something like, "Hey, I've been really busy, will post when I have more time," but he didn't. As I've said above, and as a few others (such as Toto and Haredas, iirc?) have also expressed, an inactive townie is completely dead weight, and the fact that they will contribute literally nothing to the town, or to the entire game actually, means that there's no good reason to keep them around. So having two of them (in the form of Inazuma and Brûlée) is even worse.
Boa Sandersonia
Sep 29 2016, 03:08 AM
I'm saying I want Funkfreed lynched because I want to know if the Mafia has a posting requirement. That confirmation could mean at least one lurking player, maybe Inuzuma, is scum too. Bascially, Funkfreed is my top suspect and I want him lynched today, not an inactive player.
As weird as Funkfreed's behavior is, to me, his comment sounds more like a townie foolishly making a soft claim, or just meaning something else entirely and being confusing, than a Mafia with a posting requirement. There's no denying some of the stuff he's said and done has been strange (and as you can see, I've called him out on that in this post), but I'm not sold enough about him being scum (yet, at least) that I'd be willing to lynch him over an inactive player. If Brûlée and Inazuma show up and start actually doing something, I'd reconsider, or if Funkfreed says/does enough more weird stuff to really make me think he's scum, then I'll also reconsider. But for the time being, I consider the inactive people to be the major problem here.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Merry

@Aphelandra: What about you? Are you ok with lynching Bluree or Inazuma Today?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · The Dungeon · Next Topic »
Locked Topic