Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Locked Topic
Day 1 - Darkness Falls
Topic Started: Sep 28 2016, 12:00 AM (6,807 Views)
Gan Fall
Member Avatar
GOD
Johnny
Sep 29 2016, 09:37 AM
I take issue with the Inazuma claim for another reason. The silencer apparently prevented you from posting right?

What prevented you from lurking/reading the posts?
To be fair to Brother Inazuma, the board is readable as a guest, so he has the privilege to read the posts without logging in.

Though I am still suspicious about him, for the reasons I just posted not long ago.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Funkfreed
Member Avatar

Funkfreed
Sep 29 2016, 09:39 AM
Gan Fall
Sep 29 2016, 09:28 AM
Funkfreed
Sep 29 2016, 09:27 AM
Great post ganfall it convinced me
Inazuma had lots of time to find a good and detailed 500 words post but instead he gave us such little detail
I find that scummy
Um, magnificient-beast, brother Inazuma claimed to only be able to post 50 words, not 500.
Okay my fault i mistyped
When put it in this site it was 46 words what he said hecould say


I cannot post because of silence item I also cant lynch


And have the rest39 words atleast saying how or where did he get it he had 24 hours to think of such post
Well damn i forgot to place sites link
Here you go wordcounter.net
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Toto
Member Avatar
A Hole New World
Johnny
Sep 29 2016, 09:37 AM
I take issue with the Inazuma claim for another reason. The silencer apparently prevented you from posting right?

What prevented you from lurking/reading the posts?

I noticed this as well, but my senility must be getting to me, because I forgot to bring it up. I spent quite a lot of time reading posts, especially early in the day, and I never once saw the rascal lurking. This does not bother me on the same level as the rest, but I would expect any stand-up companion to keep interest in what we discuss.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Aphelandra
Member Avatar
All I wanna be is the one who gets to see a giant woman
Toto
Sep 29 2016, 09:33 AM
Aphelandra
Sep 29 2016, 07:00 AM
And now with people's weariness of lynching Brulee, and Inazuma explaining himself, our two possible lynches are probably gone. As much as I hate it, I'm probably going to go no lynch unless we're able to come to a consensus.

Young girl, you seem to be doing positively everything in your power to discourage voting. I cannot say I am pleased. Oh, Inazuma offered an explanation, so let's believe them instantly and drop all pursuit! Oh, someone at some point mentioned that Charlotte could be the fool, so that's another abandoned course of action! I never even saw it as a serious consideration. If you "hate it so much," then actually try to pursue something, instead of giving up! You seem quite disingenuous to me.

I will say here and now, it will never benefit the town in any way to fear a Fool and let it affect actions. Paranoia will only be our enemy, fellow adventurers.
I explained exactly why I believed what Inazuma had said, though. Nero has made me consider 'why didn't they post sooner', though, so my thoughts are less definitive. The general feeling before Inazuma posted was 'let's vote Inazuma over Brulee, as Brulee is more likely the fool'.
The reason I was willing to vote for a no-lynch is that it was unlikely that we were going to rally enough votes for a lynch. I was writing that post as Inazuma posted, so I didn't see his message until I'd finished. Even then it took reading another player's thoughts to consider something awry.

Also, on another note: the amount of apologising in this game is too damn high! Forum Mafia sissyfest is what this is.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Domino
Member Avatar
Administrator
I'm SO sorry to interrupt, but~

With 19 players left, it takes 10 to lynch.

Funkfreed (1): Sandersonia
Sandersonia (1): Funkfreed
Inazuma (4): Johnny, Richie, Nero, Toto

Not voting (13): Aphelandra, Brulee, Dorry, Elizabello II, Gan Fall, Haredas, Inazuma, Keimi, Laki, Merry, Porsche, Salome, Ohm.

Down to about 14 hours left~
Edited by Domino, Sep 29 2016, 09:49 AM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Toto
Member Avatar
A Hole New World
Aphelandra
Sep 29 2016, 09:44 AM
I explained exactly why I believed what Inazuma had said, though. Nero has made me consider 'why didn't they post sooner', though, so my thoughts are less definitive. The general feeling before Inazuma posted was 'let's vote Inazuma over Brulee, as Brulee is more likely the fool'.
The reason I was willing to vote for a no-lynch is that it was unlikely that we were going to rally enough votes for a lynch. I was writing that post as Inazuma posted, so I didn't see his message until I'd finished. Even then it took reading another player's thoughts to consider something awry.

Also, on another note: the amount of apologising in this game is too damn high! Forum Mafia sissyfest is what this is.
You did give your reason why, but you did not seem to pause long enough to consider why anyone would use the item on Inazuma on the first day, either. Which adds up even less in my eyes. You were quick to rationalize in their favor.

"I don't think we can rally enough votes, so I'll vote for a no-lynch?" Bah, preposterous! You won't find out if enough votes come until you try to build the wagon. You can't sit there by your pretty lonesome and expect things to happen.

I acknowledge your perspective other than that. But I by no means got the "general feeling" that we were seriously fearing Charlotte to be a Fool. That does not even merit being considered an option when it comes time to decide on voting.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Ohm
Member Avatar

Toto
Sep 29 2016, 09:33 AM

I can think of no reason you would know the exact mafia and 3rd party count, and feel the need to profess that knowledge at the start of the game without explaining. Whatever you're trying to do, I think you are approaching it badly. But what does an old desert geezer know.



How many hints do I need to drop on why I do not wish to reveal why I know these thing.

Gan Fall
Sep 29 2016, 09:22 AM
Hello there fellow comrades. So, our androgynous comrade, after quite a long period of silence, posted regarding his most unfortunate situation.

Heavily based on pure assumption here, but my beard twitched a bit at the mention of a Silencer item. I am not sure whether our noble admin Pizarro got his roles from, but such was the role described in the MafiaWiki:
Silencer

It is stated rather clearly that a Silencer is role where the vile man/woman chooses a victim at night, robbing that fellow town comrade's ability to speak.
However here, our good friend Inazuma-san claimed to be put in such a situation by an item. Aside from the horrifying prospect that there are many more items lying around in dangerous hands, hindering us comrades in arms, I humbly lay down the possibility that Inazuma-san has the role of Silencer himself, and is trying to throw us off by claiming that an item has brought him such woe, leading us astray as we continue to believe that silenced comrades in the days to come are the results of items, not by one of us who has this Silencer role, along with the paranoia of dangerous items present amidst us to stir the pot.

I am leaning towards directing my lance at good sir Inazuma now, but I would like the brothers and sisters here to discuss this possibility that I just laid down before sending my judgement.


On the Inazuma situation : I am mostly concerned that it happened on day 1. We have not yet had a night fase yet something like this has happened. Is it truly because he has a role like this? Sounds unlikely. Also about the item: he might only use the term because of Boa but we cannot be sure about this. It is something worth following up upon for sure.

Charlotte Brûlée
Sep 29 2016, 09:35 AM
Ohm, You say that you can identify a person as third party and that its not opinion but fact. Then firstly, how do you know and is it risky or possibly counterproductive to say who they are or possibly what their role is?


First: I did not identify a person as third party. I only know that there is a single person who is neither town nor mafia. Second: I only identified how many threats there are for the town . I do not see the problem with it. I know the secrecy around it all is not helping but bear with me.

Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Aphelandra
Member Avatar
All I wanna be is the one who gets to see a giant woman
Toto
Sep 29 2016, 09:52 AM
Aphelandra
Sep 29 2016, 09:44 AM
I explained exactly why I believed what Inazuma had said, though. Nero has made me consider 'why didn't they post sooner', though, so my thoughts are less definitive. The general feeling before Inazuma posted was 'let's vote Inazuma over Brulee, as Brulee is more likely the fool'.
The reason I was willing to vote for a no-lynch is that it was unlikely that we were going to rally enough votes for a lynch. I was writing that post as Inazuma posted, so I didn't see his message until I'd finished. Even then it took reading another player's thoughts to consider something awry.

Also, on another note: the amount of apologising in this game is too damn high! Forum Mafia sissyfest is what this is.
You did give your reason why, but you did not seem to pause long enough to consider why anyone would use the item on Inazuma on the first day, either. Which adds up even less in my eyes. You were quick to rationalize in their favor.

"I don't think we can rally enough votes, so I'll vote for a no-lynch?" Bah, preposterous! You won't find out if enough votes come until you try to build the wagon. You can't sit there by your pretty lonesome and expect things to happen.

I acknowledge your perspective other than that. But I by no means got the "general feeling" that we were seriously fearing Charlotte to be a Fool. That does not even merit being considered an option when it comes time to decide on voting.
I considered it perfectly reasonable that an inexperienced player could try to get a 'free kill' using the silencer on day 1. Even an experienced player could realise that even with one post the silenced player wouldn't be able to adequately move themselves from being targeted. Day 1 is a very safe day to use it.

The wagon against Inazuma had little potential, and a wagon building on Brulee wouldn't have moved at all. Pardon me for thinking that getting 9 other people to follow your lead against a potential fool wouldn't move; I'll remember for next time.

Possibly lynching an odd-for-day-1 person doesn't warrant thinking about a fool at all? That ridiculous. I've already voiced my thoughts about believing there to be a third party, and fools are the most common form of such, so excuse my weariness.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Funkfreed
Member Avatar

Went to mafia wiki found out that my role is nothing that i thought and there is possible a third party
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Charlotte Brûlée
Member Avatar

Let me pose you a question Aphelandra, you say "The wagon against Inazuma had little potential, and a wagon building on Brulee wouldn't have moved at all. Pardon me for thinking that getting 9 other people to follow your lead against a potential fool wouldn't move; I'll remember for next time."

Does this mean the only reason you arent progressing me further is simply that you believe I am the embodiment of the tarot card, and thus is represented in my stand, the fool.?
Where do your suspicions lie if you say Inazuma is obviously not a worthy lynch at this point in time?
Considering that at this point all i can see from you is that you dont want to kill anyone.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
ZetaBoards - Free Forum Hosting
Free Forums. Reliable service with over 8 years of experience.
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · The Dungeon · Next Topic »
Locked Topic