| Day 3 - The Fall of Woman | |
|---|---|
| Tweet Topic Started: Oct 4 2016, 06:13 AM (2,729 Views) | |
| Richie | Oct 5 2016, 01:23 AM Post #101 |
![]()
|
My stance on the Nero/Inazum thing and why I think waiting for the next day wouldn't be that bad: Possibility 1: We lynch presumably Dorry, he turns out to be 3rd party surprisingly -> Nero's claim seems very unlikely Possibilty 2: Nero dies by the mafia's hands tonight, we find out his role. -> He probably told the truth Possibilty 3: Nero survives and can give us another report. -> More speculation to the fire, in case he tells the truth more info for us. Possibility 4: Nero survives, but claims he was roleblocked. -> Funkfreed can't say the same this time, and we probably find something out on this front. With this in mind, in this case assuming Funkfreed and Nero both aren't mafia, Scenario 4 would be the most likely, though they maybe would also try to kill Funkfreed instead. Still, with some extra power role sheninigans, I still see many upsides with resolving this only on the next day. Though I won't necessarily will try to stop an Inazuma Lynch, if that will be the most sought-out option by the end of the day. |
![]() |
|
| Aphelandra | Oct 5 2016, 01:49 AM Post #102 |
![]()
All I wanna be is the one who gets to see a giant woman
|
This is what it said, word for word. I did not make a mistake. I see 'Vanilla Town' as the role, not just 'Vanilla'. You don't usually get 'Town Detective', just 'Detective'. When 'Town' is a specific part of the role, that's probably why it's not written as 'Townie'. The reason the word 'the' is there is probable because it's a title as well. 'the Detective', 'the Doctor', 'the Vanilla Town'. As said yesterday: I believe that Nero is telling the truth based on how odd a defense 'Undercover Cop' would be, and how easily it can crumble (as it has). I've believed for a while that there's another third party, and Nero's claim aligns with that, so: Vote lynch: Inazuma Eleven. |
![]() |
|
| Porsche | Oct 5 2016, 01:56 AM Post #103 |
|
Thanks for the warm welcome guys <3 I feel so appreciated. Toto, why do you think I would lie about being silenced? I'm genuinely curious about your reasoning here. Your points on Inazuma and Nero are basically the same as what I think. And I don't like agreeing with people in this game... My suspicion of Aphelandra grows with her "Vanilla City" claim. Like... I find it very hard to believe that her Role PM would say that, for various reasons. Charlotte Brûlée is absent once more... Although I guess I'm not one to talk, but let's not fall into tu quoque-fallacies. I'm not sure why Dorry is under so much suspicion, even though I read up pretty well? Maybe I missed some things. Can the people who voted him (Elizabello, Richie, Laki) elaborate once more on why they did? The Inazuma/Nero situation is seemingly most urgent... but I'm not so sure about that. In any case, I would choose to lynch Inazuma instead of Nero, because of logical reasons explained earlier. And right now, I am very inclined to believe Nero is telling the truth (I also explained why earlier). Inazuma on the other hand is not helping his own cause; he's just hellbent on getting Nero lynched and OMGUSing him, while almost completely ignoring everything else going on. So I am going to assume Inazuma is, in fact, Third Party. But. Okay. Now no matter how you look at it, we have to get rid of Third Parties. They are anti-Town. BUT, so far, we have no reason to believe there is a killing Third Party. At least - I'm going to assume the two kills we had were Mafia kills. A Mafia without killing would be What I'm trying to say is, if I could help it, I would rather catch another Mafia today than lynch a Third Party. Bear with me; if we leave Inazuma alive, the situation with Nero will be unresolved, and most importantly his claim will stay unconfirmed. If he really is our Cop, that's useful to us, because I assume with all this heat, the Mafia would only go after the Cop if they were entirely sure. I feel like if we check Nero's story by lynching Inazuma, we've definitely lost him. And a (non-killing?) Third Party staying alive another Night won't harm us as much as a Mafia member staying alive another night. Then, of course, the plan would be to lynch a Mafia player. I already said I have some suspicions. Now. Questions. Aphelandra! - Can you recap in your own words what exactly Gan Fall's scumslip was? - What was it that made you decide to vote Gan Fall after all? Charlotte Brûlée! - You thought yesterday Gan Fall might have been a Fool. Do you still think it's possible there is a Fool in the game? Any other possible roles or mechanics we should be wary of? - Do you have any actual suspects? Laki! - Why are you voting Dorry? - Yesterday you voted Gan Fall quite quickly, because he slipped and of course that's something you react to immediately. But after doing so, what was next on your list of priorities? What caught your attention on Day 1 and Day 2? That's all I have for now... |
![]() |
|
| Toto | Oct 5 2016, 02:12 AM Post #104 |
|
A Hole New World
|
Not that I was genuinely entertaining the idea, but perhaps to incriminate Inazuma or make the town question the presence of Silencer / make the Silencer question being role-blocked. That sort of thing. |
![]() |
|
| Dorry | Oct 5 2016, 02:22 AM Post #105 |
![]()
Giant-Term Memory Loss
|
I do not believe my lynching would affect Nero's claim. |
![]() |
|
| Aphelandra | Oct 5 2016, 02:31 AM Post #106 |
![]()
All I wanna be is the one who gets to see a giant woman
|
Gan Fall's 'scumslip' was his confusing of colours. He incorrectly attributed 3rd Parties to the colour Blue instead of Green. I initially voted for him based on his replies to Sandersonia's, and then Toto's questions. His reply to Sandersonia's question was an odd line about his gauntlets, avoiding the question. His reply to Toto's was 'I pick the one that's not there!'. This was suspicious enough to me that I voted for him. I suspected Gan Fall a lot. He then revealed that the gauntlet line was an actual message that he received, making me think about a Communicator role of some sort. I somewhat believed him due to it being such an odd defense. The reasons I unvoted: - Thinking about a possible Communicator - Over 12 hours left in the day - I thought there were already 8 votes on him (there were 7) - I wasn't sure of myself in voting him Then, I voted for him again when I got flak for unvoting, reasoning that if the lynch went through and he flipped Mafia, and my vote was retracted, then I'd be a big suspect. |
![]() |
|
| Toto | Oct 5 2016, 02:37 AM Post #107 |
|
A Hole New World
|
Oh ho, my enormous compatriot, is this really all you have to say for yourself so far? Still not going to actually analyze what's going on, give your own input, give (belated) impressions of the previous day, ask questions... anything? And making a comment that does not address anything currently in discussion, no less. You're doing a good job of making me want to lynch you, after all! |
![]() |
|
| Johnny | Oct 5 2016, 03:01 AM Post #108 |
|
Robert Townie Jr.
|
Well it looks like it's clear what to do today. Vote Lynch: Inazuma |
![]() |
|
| Dorry | Oct 5 2016, 03:07 AM Post #109 |
![]()
Giant-Term Memory Loss
|
I'm not elaborating on anything because I've pretty much been left in the dirt by all this discourse; as a newer player, I've been unable to completely deduce the full workings of this game and the roles involved. So I do not want to make a rash decision and lynch Inazuma or Nero since I do not fully know what makes them scummy. Gan Fall's case was quickly obvious, but this debate seems to have its roots from Day 1. Honestly, you can lynch me all you want, as certain real-life events have taken up my time and I don't really care if I die anymore. But you will get no benefit from lynching me, there will be one less person on your side and the percentage of mafia members will only increase... |
![]() |
|
| Charlotte Brûlée | Oct 5 2016, 03:10 AM Post #110 |
|
As Gan Fall flip didnt come up as a fool, regardless of what my opinion is i could be wrong but id like to think there might not be one after all. Suspecting anyone in particular? I do. Not that any of them are accurate at the given time (most likely). My focus is more; Considering first 3 days, i thought gan fall was townie, clearly not, porsche didnt post now they are, and although i understand why mafia would kill fruit lady, but god damn.. Something i find interesting is that Aphelandra removes vote and then puts it back on due to being pulled up about it (nobody bats an eye, but when Dorry votes and unvotes and thats scummy?) something doesnt seem right.. Of course i could say that about anything, that it seems fishy and such, but it does seem odd to not just me right? |
![]() |
|
| Go to Next Page | |
| « Previous Topic · The Dungeon · Next Topic » |







9:06 PM Jul 11