Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Locked Topic
Day 5 - A Moment of Silence
Topic Started: Oct 9 2016, 05:07 PM (1,993 Views)
Elizabello II
Member Avatar

Back, reading up.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Elizabello II
Member Avatar

Not much happened really. Still no explanation from Ohm. Did anybody else get anything from Johnny or was it only one time. Keimi would be my highest suspect but I'm much more confused by who else would be on the team. So far probably:
Keimi
Johnny, Ohm
Richie, Laki, Porsche
Toto, Haredas, Merry
Dorry
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Elizabello II
Member Avatar

Oh, and to answer Toto's question. I was never hesitant to vote. I clearly stated my intent to vote and who each day. I'm generally concerned about ending a day prematurely and will not do so without confirming. I also don't really care whether I vote as long as the right lynch happens. If I'm opposed to a lynch I will also make that clear (not like there was much opportunity in this game so far). Only exception to all said above was yesterday when I wasn't able to participate at all for which I'm sorry especially seeing how slowly the lynch on Aphelandra formed. Good thing it went through in the end. Would have hated to have lost a day due to my absence.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Porsche
Member Avatar

Merry
 
Huh?
You "think" is right because I'm not in that category. I was one of the first people to notice and point out Aphelandra's scummy behavior. Not to say that gives me any credit because Aphelandra WAS an easy bus. I'm just saying I'm not in that category.
But to answer your question it'd be easier to point out who is not in my suspect pool because it's a smaller group:
Dorry
Johnny*
*Johnny is a little special because if he's a ]Godfather then Nero's report could be moot. But right now we have a Cop report who said he's Town soo...I'll put him up there.
Suspect Pool (and I'll even do it in order from greatest to least):
Keimi: No help at all in lynching any of the Mafia. Like, absolutely nothing.
Elizabello: Suspicious inactivity
Richie: Still suspicious of his posts and claim related to Aphelandra who turned out to be Mafia.
Ohm: Something about him having unexplained knowledge of the game but being of little help in the actual game is throwing me off.
Haredas: You know, people keep saying how easy Aphelandra's lynch was Yesterday because it's true, but why did you not notice anything wrong until it was voted on and explained? Or did you definitely notice it but hoped for miracle if you didn't mention anything?
Porsche: Seems to have only picked up activity after 2 Mafia buddies lynched as if to pick up slack.
Laki: Seems to be keeping up with events even with a lack of activity but that doesn't translate to helping Town.
Toto: It's one thing to bus your opponent but to do it on something as small and technical as a color slip that everyone else might have missed? Not off the hook though and shouldn't be.
Fair enough, you did name her a few times. On Day 2 you made a list of Aph's scummy behaviour after Gan Fall's slip, but on Day 3 you didn't go much further than to call her suspicious (along with 4 others(!)).

Your suspect pool is literally everyone except for the cleared Townies...? I get it, nobody is cleared and everyone is suspicious in some way, but you're doing the same thing as Haredas; just summing up everybody and calling everyone at least "somewhat" suspicious. Well, at least you put them in order. So I gather you want to pursue Keimi today too?

Merry
 
Yeah, but I could be wrong. Very wrong.
Disclaimer?

Toto
 
Since Johnny is practically completely cleared, I'm looking at Merry the most out of your list. Laki is also possible.
See, you put Merry on the list too. Why does he stand out to you more than Laki? She wasn't after Aphelandra at all before D4.

Toto
 
Toto: Why is this guy still alive? I mean, seriously. He should have been offed days ago.
Good point.
But thanks for sharing your possible Mafia teams.

It looks like everyone has Keimi on the very top of their suspect list today. I think we should definitely follow up on that. It's happened too often in a game that one player kept coming back as a main suspect, but never actually got lynched and then it was too late.
I'm going to reread to organize my thoughts, and then if my suspicions are reinforced, I will vote Keimi too. In any case we should give her time to answer and defend herself. And of course there are other people who urgently need to show up and talk.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Dorry
Member Avatar
Giant-Term Memory Loss
Toto
Oct 10 2016, 09:43 AM
Dorry, you are ultra-confirmed town, so your input is invaluable. Any input other than on Ohm? Did you and Brulee discuss or plan anything interesting that you want to share?
Brulee and I didn't really discuss much due to her inactivity and me essentially being lost. Just the day's events. I do agree that Elizabello's changes in behaviors are somewhat suspicious, and I am also suspicious of Porsche, who seems to have eased back into this game with little trouble. But I don't really have enough evidence to truly go after either just yet, so

Vote Lynch: Keimi
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Domino
Member Avatar
Administrator
Not sure if that's your vote or Toto's reiterated for some reason, so I guess let's clarify that the vote needs to be in the body of your post to be counted.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Haredas
Member Avatar

Merry
Oct 10 2016, 05:48 AM
To clarify, my 2nd post on Day 4 had nothing to do with you so when you asked was it directed at you it really confused me. My 2nd post was simply to point out the obviousness of my vote and Aphelandra's guilt. I just found it peculiar you didn't mention her until the next day (real life day from October 6th to the 7th).
Fair enough. You can read my response to Toto that talks about my actions.

I would like to request that we hold off on the lynch for awhile until we hear from Johnny and Ohm.
I also have some input I would like to share but won't have time to make a big post for a few hours from now (3-5 pm EST)

I really don't want another Aphelandra situation where I come back intending to post and find out the mafia hammered and ended all discussion.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Dorry
Member Avatar
Giant-Term Memory Loss
Formatting mistake

Vote Lynch: Keimi
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Toto
Member Avatar
A Hole New World
Elizabello II
Oct 10 2016, 12:26 PM
Oh, and to answer Toto's question. I was never hesitant to vote. I clearly stated my intent to vote and who each day. I'm generally concerned about ending a day prematurely and will not do so without confirming. I also don't really care whether I vote as long as the right lynch happens. If I'm opposed to a lynch I will also make that clear (not like there was much opportunity in this game so far). Only exception to all said above was yesterday when I wasn't able to participate at all for which I'm sorry especially seeing how slowly the lynch on Aphelandra formed. Good thing it went through in the end. Would have hated to have lost a day due to my absence.
Thanks for answering, ho ho. But be that as it may, actions speak louder than words. You could have been an earlier vote on the wagons, and you show no personal conviction if you're just waiting around to vote "if needed." Plus you can easily say you would have voted to complete the lynch on the two mafia we got, but we won't know since the situation never came up. Not to mention being completely gone the past day, in which you of course did not state any intent to vote (or not).

Porsche
Oct 10 2016, 01:09 PM
See, you put Merry on the list too. Why does he stand out to you more than Laki? She wasn't after Aphelandra at all before D4.

Nothing specific that I haven't already mentioned at the moment (still haven't re-read). Other than the issue with Laki during the Gan Fall interrogation, the difference between the two is more gut feeling at this point.

Porsche
Oct 10 2016, 01:09 PM
But thanks for sharing your possible Mafia teams.

Keep in mind those were purely activity level-based, and were only two possible example teams among people I could see as scum.

Dorry
Oct 10 2016, 03:05 PM
I do agree that Elizabello's changes in behaviors are somewhat suspicious, and I am also suspicious of Porsche, who seems to have eased back into this game with little trouble.

Thanks for this input. And I share your concern regarding Porsche.

Haredas
Oct 10 2016, 05:52 PM
I would like to request that we hold off on the lynch for awhile until we hear from Johnny and Ohm.
I also have some input I would like to share but won't have time to make a big post for a few hours from now (3-5 pm EST)

I really don't want another Aphelandra situation where I come back intending to post and find out the mafia hammered and ended all discussion.

Yes, let's not rush a lynch this time.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Porsche
Member Avatar

What? Dorry, what do you mean I "eased back into this game"? And Toto what do you mean by it?

I'm still rereading and arranging my notes, I have to leave until tomorrow morning but I hope the Day will still be going on by then, so I'm not voting just yet.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · The Dungeon · Next Topic »
Locked Topic