Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Locked Topic
Day 5 - A Moment of Silence
Topic Started: Oct 9 2016, 05:07 PM (1,992 Views)
Merry

Porsche
Oct 10 2016, 01:09 PM
Your suspect pool is literally everyone except for the cleared Townies...? I get it, nobody is cleared and everyone is suspicious in some way, but you're doing the same thing as Haredas; just summing up everybody and calling everyone at least "somewhat" suspicious. Well, at least you put them in order. So I gather you want to pursue Keimi today too?


Yes, I am but I want to say a little bit more on this subject.

I feel like something bigger is being missed and I can't quite put my finger on it, or it'd be more appropriate to say "who". When it comes right down to it Keimi feels too easy, like she's being willingly handed over to us. Gan Fall and Aphelandra felt too easy and they were right on the mark. Hell, so far all of the Mafia have felt too easy (including possible Mafia Keimi). I haven't played a ton of Mafia but enough to know that it usually isn't this easy. Town has had a perfect lynching record so far. I wish Ohm could come on to clarify his statements/info on the player pool but if the game started off with 5 Mafia (I hope that included Nero) then there might be 2 (or 3) left.

Which makes me very worried about the likely potential that there's a more experienced Mafia member hiding behind their buddies and my least suspected folks are there for all the wrong reasons.

Porsche
 
Merry
 
Yeah, but I could be wrong. Very wrong.
Disclaimer?


Correlation doesn't imply causation. Just because the people at the top of my list are the most suspicious to me doesn't mean that suspicion is caused by their scumminess. See above worries.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Your post asking about Keimi reminds me of something. You never answered my Day 4 question near the end and if you missed it you'd be forgiven because it was near the end of the Day.

http://s15.zetaboards.com/Dungeon_Crawl_Mafia/single/?p=10005310&t=10035215

The question was basically, 'Why have you not helped lynch?' Sure, you came on at the end there and helped lynch Aphelandra with a late vote but that doesn't explain your vote absence for our previous 2 lynches. And it's kinda funny you came on the next Day and asked Keimi a similar question without answering mine.

http://s15.zetaboards.com/Dungeon_Crawl_Mafia/single/?p=10005637&t=10036966

Quoted here: 'Keimi, it's time to tell us a little more about yourself. Is there a reason you never vote?
You know we all want you to be more active. What do you think you could contribute to this Town? Could you list some suspects?'


-Porsche

As I ask again a question in the same vein. Why are you so active now with votes as opposed to the first half of the game?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Porsche
Member Avatar

Merry
Oct 10 2016, 07:27 PM
Your post asking about Keimi reminds me of something. You never answered my Day 4 question near the end and if you missed it you'd be forgiven because it was near the end of the Day.

http://s15.zetaboards.com/Dungeon_Crawl_Mafia/single/?p=10005310&t=10035215

The question was basically, 'Why have you not helped lynch?' Sure, you came on at the end there and helped lynch Aphelandra with a late vote but that doesn't explain your vote absence for our previous 2 lynches. And it's kinda funny you came on the next Day and asked Keimi a similar question without answering mine.

http://s15.zetaboards.com/Dungeon_Crawl_Mafia/single/?p=10005637&t=10036966

Quoted here: 'Keimi, it's time to tell us a little more about yourself. Is there a reason you never vote?
You know we all want you to be more active. What do you think you could contribute to this Town? Could you list some suspects?'


-Porsche

As I ask again a question in the same vein. Why are you so active now with votes as opposed to the first half of the game?
I have addressed this in an earlier post today. I know I've been very inactive in the first few Days, but I explained why that was and I am starting to make up for it now.
With Gan Fall's wagon, I simply missed an entire Day. With Inazuma, the lynch was already completed by the time I could check back in.

I did miss your question, sorry about that. But saying I can't blame Keimi for her absence, because I was absent myself, would be a logical fallacy. Keimi has only come in quickly to apologize, but she hasn't actually contributed yet. I've been reading and rereading yesterday and today, I already voiced some of my concerns, suspicions and questions, and I'm coming with more later.

As for the reason why I am much more active now, it's simply because I have more time. Those first few Days I was away often, or didn't have access to a computer, and couldn't participate as much as I wanted to. But now I do, so now I am playing the way I would play normally. I can't believe people are making a problem out of me being active and I hope this is not going to be an issue because it's distracting from any real discussion.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Toto
Member Avatar
A Hole New World
I dunno Merry, do you seem to be setting yourself up to be wrong. I'm sure there's at least one experienced player as part of the Mafia, but we have to lynch somebody, so if you want to find a better target than Keimi, feel free to convince us. I'm not dead-set on Keimi.

Porsche
Oct 10 2016, 06:52 PM
What? Dorry, what do you mean I "eased back into this game"? And Toto what do you mean by it?

Just that nobody really seemed to question/suspect you during your absent period. Even now that you're back, you've been pretty low-activity overall until right now.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Toto
Member Avatar
A Hole New World
Toto
Oct 10 2016, 08:19 PM
I dunno Merry, do you seem to be setting yourself up to be wrong.
The stupid old man meant to say "you do seem," not "do you seem."
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Merry

I don't have a better target than Keimi Today. I'm just getting my thoughts out there and, yes, we do have to lynch somebody.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Haredas
Member Avatar

I have some things to write up but Johnny, I see you are on the forums but have not posted yet any reason for this?
Although I hate to bring up the whole "Silencer" thing if you are going to make that claim would you kindly park yourself in the rules topic as a way of showing us you are claiming to be silenced?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Haredas
Member Avatar

In no meaningful order things I noticed:
- Gan Fall, Aphelandra and Merry from what I remember were the one who on early days were calling attention to the fact that Porsche was inactive.
http://s15.zetaboards.com/Dungeon_Crawl_Mafia/single/?p=10003934&t=10030370
not extremely hard evidence or anything but it stood out to me.

Ohm says something strange here "why you gave the silencer"
http://s15.zetaboards.com/Dungeon_Crawl_Mafia/single/?p=10003907&t=10030370
Also his question about suspecting Keimi not proof of anything but makes me feel like they could be a team.
http://s15.zetaboards.com/Dungeon_Crawl_Mafia/single/?p=10003910&t=10030370

Richie: mentions fool
http://s15.zetaboards.com/Dungeon_Crawl_Mafia/single/?p=10003114&t=10027684
Aphelandra: says that it is the general feeling is that Brulee is the fool
http://s15.zetaboards.com/Dungeon_Crawl_Mafia/single/?p=10003172&t=10027684
Richie mentions twice that he believe Aphelandra (not directly related but he also stated earlier that he can understand suspecting Boa who turned out to be Town)
http://s15.zetaboards.com/Dungeon_Crawl_Mafia/single/?p=10003871&t=10030370
http://s15.zetaboards.com/Dungeon_Crawl_Mafia/single/?p=10003999&t=10030370

the dynamic between these two is questionable.


I have an errand so I can't post more but I will be back to have a more "Judging" imput since people seem to be wanting that from me.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Johnny
Member Avatar
Robert Townie Jr.
Hooo boy rereading everything is taking forever
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Johnny
Member Avatar
Robert Townie Jr.
So far my readings are pointing me here:

Vote Lynch: Richie

Why you always lion?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Keimi

Haredas
 
I meant how you seemed to be going from "Inazuma is suspicious" to "People who suspect Inazuma are suspicious" and back again. You also brought up points against Richie and Ohm but just kinda abandoned them when people focused on other things.

Never said people who suspect Inazuma were suspicious. Ohm was just a note I made about it being kind of weird, I'll go into more of that later. Ritchie made a post that I found to be suspicious, so I pointed it out, he later did things I felt were very townie.

Anyways, I have no delusions that I'll escape being lynched today, so I'm not going to waste any more energy on defending myself today. I'm a Vanilla Townie so it's not a huge loss. Instead I'll just leave you with what I got, perhaps it will be of use in your scumhunting to come.

Dorry, as confirmed town as it gets I'd say. Next.

Elizabello II, probably one of my higher suspects. Was one of the ones that went after Dorry when there was clearly a threat between Nero and Inazuma.

Haredas, was the first to notice and point out Aphelandra's pm goof. Even though he did so as a joke I can't see him pointing her post out like that if he was a scumbuddy.

Johnny, confirmed town by cop, no need to worry about Godfather possibilities this soon.

Laki, was in the same group as Elizabello, but was very swift and detailed with reasoning.

Merry, I can't seem to pin them and they're the player I always seem to forget is here. That kind of scares me but that's not exactly damning.

Ohm, ok so I'd really like to here exactly what it is that lets him know the roles. As it stands it appears to be one off in that he knows the ratio and that's it. Not sure why we can't just have him claim the whole role. Could be he thought making such an outlandish claim at the beginning would give him a lot of credit, the fact he was wrong at first adds credence to this theory.

Porche, started out inactive but has heavily picked up since then. Has been aggressive in questioning. Not a ton to go on due to the early inactivity.

Ritchie, as I've stated, I was suspicious of his post pointing out Inazuma. Since then i noticed he was the one to ask about Aphelandra about her role pm, real dangerous play if he was her partner. He failed to pick up on her error though. I have to forgive this though as I would have probably done the exact same thing. Asking the question alone makes him innocent in my eyes, unless he was betting on this being a no vanilla setup. Still a huge bet.

Toto, heavily active in the lynching game. Was the one to point out Gan Fall's error. He's either a townie or a mafia that's been all in on busing his friends.


That's what I got. Like I said I'm not going to waste effort defending my actions or inactions anymore. We all know you're going to lynch me, only my flip will satisfy you. I'll do what I can to answer any questions about others though.

Vote Lynch: Elizabello II
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · The Dungeon · Next Topic »
Locked Topic