Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Locked Topic
Day 1: The Adventure Begins; Let's Start Exploring
Topic Started: Oct 20 2016, 11:00 PM (2,314 Views)
Dandy
Member Avatar
Space Dandy
Pappug
Oct 21 2016, 01:24 AM
Vote Lynch: Guilmon

No, I think 24 hours is plenty of time to come on and with this kind of setup lynching is our best and only weapon in discovering Mafia. Well, besides reading and analyzing posts of course but if the user isn't posting what's there to read?
Quote:
 
Power roles arent the only bits of information that are valuable. Useful? Sure, and you do bring up a point that I hadnt thought about. But at the core, seeing who mafia goes for in a pool of active players does give us information.

Bottom line is that I find a larger group of loose activity to be less useful down the line than a smaller group of actually active individuals. Otherwise at one point the valuable ones get knocked out and we are at the mercy of inactive to even lynch.

Also, natural observation throughout the progress of the game means a lot less if we establish that it is fine for people to hang along being unhelpful. Gives us less to work with, not more.


So if Guillmon ends up posting a couple of decent posts, you would still want to lynch someone? And the criteria would be activity?
Is reducing that player pool of potential targets from 11 to 10 such a step forward?
Don´t get me wrong, I agree that organized activity in a smaller group is better than loose and disjointed searchs, but at this point of the game, loose/disjointed activity is kind of expected.

Quote:
 
Vote Lynch: Guilmon

No, I think 24 hours is plenty of time to come on and with this kind of setup lynching is our best and only weapon in discovering Mafia. Well, besides reading and analyzing posts of course but if the user isn't posting what's there to read?


Mind explaining this? Without using Mimi´s logic.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Dandy
Member Avatar
Space Dandy
First quote´s Mimi´s. Forget the misplaced Pappug one at the beggining.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Dandy
Member Avatar
Space Dandy
Yoshikage Kira
Oct 21 2016, 01:35 AM
What if Guilmon was silenced however? [/JOKE]

I still would give him a little more time. We have about 40 hours left this day, I'll begin to worry if he doesn't post in the next 24hrs.
What if Guilmon is THE FOOOOOOOOOOL? (/Ikid)
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Mimi
Member Avatar
Digimon
Dandy
Oct 21 2016, 02:05 AM
Pappug
Oct 21 2016, 01:24 AM
Vote Lynch: Guilmon

No, I think 24 hours is plenty of time to come on and with this kind of setup lynching is our best and only weapon in discovering Mafia. Well, besides reading and analyzing posts of course but if the user isn't posting what's there to read?
Quote:
 
Power roles arent the only bits of information that are valuable. Useful? Sure, and you do bring up a point that I hadnt thought about. But at the core, seeing who mafia goes for in a pool of active players does give us information.

Bottom line is that I find a larger group of loose activity to be less useful down the line than a smaller group of actually active individuals. Otherwise at one point the valuable ones get knocked out and we are at the mercy of inactive to even lynch.

Also, natural observation throughout the progress of the game means a lot less if we establish that it is fine for people to hang along being unhelpful. Gives us less to work with, not more.


So if Guillmon ends up posting a couple of decent posts, you would still want to lynch someone? And the criteria would be activity?
Is reducing that player pool of potential targets from 11 to 10 such a step forward?
Don´t get me wrong, I agree that organized activity in a smaller group is better than loose and disjointed searchs, but at this point of the game, loose/disjointed activity is kind of expected.

Quote:
 
Vote Lynch: Guilmon

No, I think 24 hours is plenty of time to come on and with this kind of setup lynching is our best and only weapon in discovering Mafia. Well, besides reading and analyzing posts of course but if the user isn't posting what's there to read?


Mind explaining this? Without using Mimi´s logic.
Guilmon is not the only one who has failed to show up today so that question is an easy yes.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Dandy
Member Avatar
Space Dandy
Mimi
Oct 21 2016, 02:13 AM
Dandy
Oct 21 2016, 02:05 AM
Pappug
Oct 21 2016, 01:24 AM
Vote Lynch: Guilmon

No, I think 24 hours is plenty of time to come on and with this kind of setup lynching is our best and only weapon in discovering Mafia. Well, besides reading and analyzing posts of course but if the user isn't posting what's there to read?
Quote:
 
Power roles arent the only bits of information that are valuable. Useful? Sure, and you do bring up a point that I hadnt thought about. But at the core, seeing who mafia goes for in a pool of active players does give us information.

Bottom line is that I find a larger group of loose activity to be less useful down the line than a smaller group of actually active individuals. Otherwise at one point the valuable ones get knocked out and we are at the mercy of inactive to even lynch.

Also, natural observation throughout the progress of the game means a lot less if we establish that it is fine for people to hang along being unhelpful. Gives us less to work with, not more.


So if Guillmon ends up posting a couple of decent posts, you would still want to lynch someone? And the criteria would be activity?
Is reducing that player pool of potential targets from 11 to 10 such a step forward?
Don´t get me wrong, I agree that organized activity in a smaller group is better than loose and disjointed searchs, but at this point of the game, loose/disjointed activity is kind of expected.

Quote:
 
Vote Lynch: Guilmon

No, I think 24 hours is plenty of time to come on and with this kind of setup lynching is our best and only weapon in discovering Mafia. Well, besides reading and analyzing posts of course but if the user isn't posting what's there to read?


Mind explaining this? Without using Mimi´s logic.
Guilmon is not the only one who has failed to show up today so that question is an easy yes.
Come on Baby. That´s the easy way out.
You know what I meant.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Hinata Hyuga
Member Avatar
Naruto
Everyone should know by now that green is the best color to be.

With 14 players, it takes 8 to lynch.

Lelouch vi Britannia (1): Dandy
Mimi (1): Yoshikage Kira
Guilmon (2): Lelouch vi Britannia, Pappug

Not Voting (10): Astro Boy, Claire Stanfield, Dr. Tenma, Edward Weevil, Guilmon, Hanamichi Sakuragi, Isaac Dian, Kakashi Hatake, Mimi, Yuuki Rito
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Yuuki Rito
Member Avatar
To Love-ru
Mimi
Oct 21 2016, 12:42 AM
Dandy
Oct 21 2016, 12:26 AM
Mimi
Oct 21 2016, 12:11 AM
As for votes I think I want to wait for Guilmon before doing my part... if he fails to speak then I think we need to talk about possible action. If not, then I think getting rid of one of the many silly boys will do our ship some good.
Why?

Because I have the opposite opinion.
Scaring meek boys who refuse to participate or help into being active does multiple things

1- the bad guys wont have an easy kill where they can just knock off someone who hasnt done anything, and forces them to commit to a kill that can actually be traced or give us information
2- it lets us know what we can expect of our shipmates and who aims to be consistently valuable as opposed to those who only become valuable when they want to hide mean intentions
3- Our ship and our friends will all be stronger if we commit as a group to help or accept our loss if we fail to keep up

Do you have a different idea? because raising conversation based on just what people decide to wear is just mean and not really helpful at all
I agree with Mimi here. Guilmon is more than useless right now, but if he lasts another day like this than he becomes dangerous to keep around.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Mimi
Member Avatar
Digimon
Dandy: ew, dont call me baby >_<

The quote is far too gigantic to be practical, so I'm dropping it.

You should be specific about the answers you want. Not going to get far myself if I make assumptions about what people want from me.

But if I HAD to assume in this one, the answer is still yes. I think its still a good idea to call out the inactive people or the lowest contributors hoping that moves them into action. I thought I had already said that but I must not be being clear? '_';;

What I wonder now is why with two other people so far stating similar opinions (or is it one? ugh, these names are so hard to remember), you find it important to be interviewing just me. Teasing the only girl already? tsk, how predictable.
It seems you think you have a way with girls, but I may be far too pure for you =P
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Yoshikage Kira
Member Avatar
Jojo's Bizarre Adventure
Mimi
Oct 21 2016, 02:13 AM
Guilmon is not the only one who has failed to show up today so that question is an easy yes.
You seem very hectic, lady. The day hasn't lasted even 4 hours yet, but you already want to throw shade at anyone who hasn' t shown up today. You might not have as nice of a watch as I have, but you should know that there are different time zones in play here.

I would talk about someone being inactive in 20 hours, but right now it feels rather early, don't you think?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Mimi
Member Avatar
Digimon
Yoshikage Kira
Oct 21 2016, 02:53 AM
Mimi
Oct 21 2016, 02:13 AM
Guilmon is not the only one who has failed to show up today so that question is an easy yes.
You seem very hectic, lady. The day hasn't lasted even 4 hours yet, but you already want to throw shade at anyone who hasn' t shown up today. You might not have as nice of a watch as I have, but you should know that there are different time zones in play here.

I would talk about someone being inactive in 20 hours, but right now it feels rather early, don't you think?
Stating my view doesnt mean I'm not waiting. You may have noticed that unlike others I havent thrown a vote yet.

Why not call the people who have voted already hasty? ... oh, I see, because the first thing you did was vote...

You boys are so rude!
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · The Surface of Rakuen · Next Topic »
Locked Topic