Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Locked Topic
Day 1: The Adventure Begins; Let's Start Exploring
Topic Started: Oct 20 2016, 11:00 PM (2,313 Views)
Dandy
Member Avatar
Space Dandy
I also asked Pappug to expand his idea.

Just so it stays clear, if everyone ends up giving their two cents (and by this I mean a meaningful contribution) until the end of the Day, then, and taking into account the kind of setup we have, I would rather not lynch anyone.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Yoshikage Kira
Member Avatar
Jojo's Bizarre Adventure
Mimi
Oct 21 2016, 02:57 AM
Stating my view doesnt mean I'm not waiting. You may have noticed that unlike others I havent thrown a vote yet.

Why not call the people who have voted already hasty? ... oh, I see, because the first thing you did was vote...

You boys are so rude!
But they seem to concentrate and pressure Guilmon only, who wasn't even able to appear on Day 0. I still find it rather hasty, but reasonable in a way. You already seem to be ready to jump at the next best person if Guilmon shows up.

And obviously my vote wasn't meant to be taken seriously. It still was intersting to see you not adressing it at all until now, despite it being on your person this early.

Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Isaac Dian
Member Avatar
Baccano!
It seems silly to lynch someone so early, when we have near zero information to go on. Just makes the Mafia's job easier.

If Guilmon still hasn't posted later and we have no better leads, sure, let's talk about it then.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Mimi
Member Avatar
Digimon
Yoshikage Kira
Oct 21 2016, 03:05 AM
Mimi
Oct 21 2016, 02:57 AM
Stating my view doesnt mean I'm not waiting. You may have noticed that unlike others I havent thrown a vote yet.

Why not call the people who have voted already hasty? ... oh, I see, because the first thing you did was vote...

You boys are so rude!
But they seem to concentrate and pressure Guilmon only, who wasn't even able to appear on Day 0. I still find it rather hasty, but reasonable in a way. You already seem to be ready to jump at the next best person if Guilmon shows up.

And obviously my vote wasn't meant to be taken seriously. It still was intersting to see you not adressing it at all until now, despite it being on your person this early.

I'm not jumping at anyone as much as establishing that as a group we need to define the value of being active. Once we reach that point where someone stands out in their silence then yea, we can talk about jumping at them or not, but for now the conversation is still theoretical.

Regarding your vote, it was obviously fluff which is why I chose not to respond. Sure, I make it clear I don't enjoy being with just you boys, but voting for someone over "being rude" sounds like a useless thing to do, much like dandy's vote.
Really only brought it up now because the first person to vote in the day calling others hasty sounded ironic.

More importantly, what are your ACTUAL views? Fluff vote aside? Are you also willing to carry inactive players through the game?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Hanamichi Sakuragi
Member Avatar
Slam Dunk
Oh, Yohei and Takamiya saw this creature in an alley the other day when they were playing Pokemon Go, maybe it's that missing guy, I hope they didn't get into a fight...

There are only 14 of us here, ya know. Lynching someone to force a safer kill will result in 1 less person than we'd have without a lynch. See, I can do math! ...I think...

Someone not being here at all indicates more that they are just...not here, not that they're mafia. Makes no sense to lynch someone who has a high chance of being a townie, and if they ARE mafia, they're a highly incompetent one. If I see this red creature around, I'll be sure to give him a headbutt to get info from him...
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Yoshikage Kira
Member Avatar
Jojo's Bizarre Adventure
Mimi
Oct 21 2016, 03:15 AM
I'm not jumping at anyone as much as establishing that as a group we need to define the value of being active. Once we reach that point where someone stands out in their silence then yea, we can talk about jumping at them or not, but for now the conversation is still theoretical.

Regarding your vote, it was obviously fluff which is why I chose not to respond. Sure, I make it clear I don't enjoy being with just you boys, but voting for someone over "being rude" sounds like a useless thing to do, much like dandy's vote.
Really only brought it up now because the first person to vote in the day calling others hasty sounded ironic.

More importantly, what are your ACTUAL views? Fluff vote aside? Are you also willing to carry inactive players through the game?
I was the second person to vote, first one was Dandy.

And no, I am not willing taking inactives through the game. But I think it's too early to call anyone "inactive" this way, as said earlier I give everyone at least 20 hours from now to show up. All in all however, I would prefer if we could live through Day 1 without a (possible mis)lynch, so I hope everyone will take part in this very conversation.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Mimi
Member Avatar
Digimon
I could swear it had been you. I seriously need to get better about all this names >_<
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Hanamichi Sakuragi
Member Avatar
Slam Dunk
Also, there's a very incorrect assumption being made that Charizard ripoff would be the only safe kill. The day is still young yes but there are people who have posted less and could be considered safe.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Pappug
Member Avatar
One Piece
Dandy
Oct 21 2016, 02:05 AM
Pappug
Oct 21 2016, 01:24 AM
Vote Lynch: Guilmon

No, I think 24 hours is plenty of time to come on and with this kind of setup lynching is our best and only weapon in discovering Mafia. Well, besides reading and analyzing posts of course but if the user isn't posting what's there to read?
Quote:
 
Power roles arent the only bits of information that are valuable. Useful? Sure, and you do bring up a point that I hadnt thought about. But at the core, seeing who mafia goes for in a pool of active players does give us information.

Bottom line is that I find a larger group of loose activity to be less useful down the line than a smaller group of actually active individuals. Otherwise at one point the valuable ones get knocked out and we are at the mercy of inactive to even lynch.

Also, natural observation throughout the progress of the game means a lot less if we establish that it is fine for people to hang along being unhelpful. Gives us less to work with, not more.


So if Guillmon ends up posting a couple of decent posts, you would still want to lynch someone? And the criteria would be activity?
Is reducing that player pool of potential targets from 11 to 10 such a step forward?
Don´t get me wrong, I agree that organized activity in a smaller group is better than loose and disjointed searchs, but at this point of the game, loose/disjointed activity is kind of expected.

Quote:
 
Vote Lynch: Guilmon

No, I think 24 hours is plenty of time to come on and with this kind of setup lynching is our best and only weapon in discovering Mafia. Well, besides reading and analyzing posts of course but if the user isn't posting what's there to read?


Mind explaining this? Without using Mimi´s logic.


Most of us are Vanilla Townies. Besides the Cop we don't have any powers to use at Night as far I know, so if we want information we can't just sit around hoping to survive through the Night as we peek under each other's blankets. We have to lynch.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Kakashi Hatake
Member Avatar
Naruto
Oh my, I show up fashionably late and i find lynches laid down for astetic reasons, which are just foolish in my sight. Just because someone wishes to write in a different color a scum does not make. The mere fact you thew that down on the first page, much less one of the first posts is disheartening.

Guilmonis another problematic problem because he has yet to post, ut he still seems to be an easy lynch because of that inactivity. I'll give him another 12 hours to show up before I decide anything on him.

For now, I am going to partake in my novel
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · The Surface of Rakuen · Next Topic »
Locked Topic