Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Locked Topic
Day 3: A Space Man Dies; You must read the original post to find out who's dead this time!
Topic Started: Oct 26 2016, 10:00 PM (2,278 Views)
Astro Boy
Member Avatar
Astro Boy
Yuuki Rito
Oct 27 2016, 08:15 AM
@Astro
I don't understand what about me can't be gathered from my posts so far. I've stated my opinions and views on many things already. My stances are pretty clear too.

Hope this helps you understand: I was asked about my thoughts on everyone I said "Weevil and Yuuki really need to show up for me to get a better read on them" this quote means exactly what it looks like I have not made a firm stance on if you are part of the town or mafia. I understand your posts and opinions I just don't know yet if they are townie or mafia.

Edward Weevil
Oct 27 2016, 10:01 AM
Issac is mostly gut feeling kakashi for day 1 thing astro boy for not being active and something else
Seriously? Did you even read my post on the first page? You think my inactivity is a ruse that I have been plotting since before the game started and before I knew my role? I pretty much said "I am going to be busy but if someone is a no show I can sub in for them and at least ACTUALLY post" and it turned out we had no shows so Faith asked me to sub in I even made goofy Takatin pictures and everything...

Claire Stanfield
Oct 27 2016, 10:21 AM
There really isn't a lot to be gleaned from Dandy's posts.

I know the day is still young but having four wagons going at the same time makes me uncomfortable. Should we mislynch today we will have 8 players left tomorrow. Which means we could not afford another mislnch then. Today is somewhat crucial because of that. What I'm trying to say is that everybody who has already voted should really make sure they know what they're doing.
I agree which is why I am going to place my vote on someone who the mafia lynch-rushing would only do us townies a favour (aside from potentially cutting short our discussions)
Mimi
Oct 27 2016, 10:23 AM
Perhaps it would also help if people commented on the wagons themselves instead of just asking them to be automatically solved for them.

- Lelouch vs Isaac I really don't know who is right I even think it is fairly likely that they are both wrong and the mafia is laughing at us all be distracted.
- Dr. Tenma has really good pro-town points, however I really feel like they are coming from someone who has mafia knowledge. I believe he is doing an outstanding job at playing the role of "pro-town" active mafia.
- Weevil I perfectly understand the wagon for him but I honestly think Tenma is going for the low hanging fruit by voting for someone who seems unable to understand info that has been spoonfed to us by the mods.

Dr. Tenma
Oct 27 2016, 10:46 AM

@Weevil you suspect Kakashi for voting you day 1? care to elaborate. And what about Astro boy's inactivity is it that gets you I mean remember he was replaced so do you mean before or after the replacement and what do you mean by "something else?"
Even though I suspect you I am glad you can see past that and ask logical questions.


Dr. Tenma
Oct 27 2016, 10:46 AM
@Claire I really don't think we need to be that nervous this early on and Mimi if there's something specific you want me to comment on let me know but I did feel it was best for the moment if I let Lelouch reply to Isaac and not muddle it up.
I think the only people who don't think we need to be nervous are the mafia
We do need to be nervous

Dr. Tenma
Oct 27 2016, 07:29 PM
If you think he's trying to intentionally confuse the town you're giving him way more credit than i am, I mean maybe his low activity is intentional but my accusation was just that he was being lazy and not bothering to read or understand the town's situation when he does post which I find scummy for reasons explained and I mean just look at his suspects they almost seem just like the people who called him out other than Isaac who is based on "gut feeling."

@Yuuki it's not set in stone yet, if the day keeps on track likely one of Lelouch or Isaac and I'm still leaning Lelouche right now but I really really want him to reply before I comment in detail there, but anyway it also depends on whether Kakashi makes good on his promise and I want to see if Weevil can even make a simple basic case against a single suspect and I want to hear more from you and Kira still.

On that note Yuuki you have finally when asked directly answered a single question about which current wagon you would choose but Mimi has a solid point against your reluctance to commit to any opinions, I mean is Isaac someone you actually suspect and if so why, if not who do you personally suspect? Now under scrutiny you have turned to asking questions but still deflecting focus away from yourself and in that respect yes I can understand Mimi's desire to lynch Yuuki but that's no different from what I'm doing so in the end this whole damn situation is as frustrating as ever.

Kira to be honest your one real post today makes you sound exactly like Yuuki, you answered the question asked just with the opposite answer as him but we have very little further insight into what you think we should do today and how to proceed which stands out in contrast to your early vote yesterday to start the Sakuragi wagon, suddenly the idea of Yuuki/Kira being partners pops into mind but really I've been associating people for having similar agendas/styles but that might be the opposite of what we're looking for. I mean guys we have 3 mafia and I'm not sure anyone other than me has actually attempted to link players as a team, well except Astro boy who said it's possible Lelouch and I are dramatic scum buddies but that's a hysterical idea to me.

I'm going to be busy for a while but I should be back around when the day is halfway over and at that point hopefully more will have happened and we can decide how to actually proceed.
^This post makes me sad that I want to lynch you I will honestly miss your smart posting if we manage to lynch you. I will just have to run the risk of dealing with the resulting madness of our remaining crewmates.




With sadness I cast my vote
Vote Lynch: Dr. Tenma
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Yuuki Rito
Member Avatar
To Love-ru
Dr. Tenma
Oct 27 2016, 07:29 PM
On that note Yuuki you have finally when asked directly answered a single question about which current wagon you would choose but Mimi has a solid point against your reluctance to commit to any opinions, I mean is Isaac someone you actually suspect and if so why, if not who do you personally suspect? Now under scrutiny you have turned to asking questions but still deflecting focus away from yourself and in that respect yes I can understand Mimi's desire to lynch Yuuki but that's no different from what I'm doing so in the end this whole damn situation is as frustrating as ever.
I've answered all of the questions posed to me in this entire game. Have you just ignored every one of my posts? As I said yesterday, I still somewhat suspect Kakashi for his voting Weevil on Day 1, and how he handled the situation, and I have a gut feeling about Kira/Claire.
I was also ready to pursue Dandy today, but as you see that didn't go so well.
I'm starting to see Isaac come off as suspicious due to Lelouch's breakdown of their conversations, so yeah, he's a suspect too.
Also I've asked a question in almost all of my posts. It's not for deflection: I just want answers.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Mimi
Member Avatar
Digimon
Nope, sorry

Unvote

Astro Boy: Time to explain your vote a bit more. Kept my vote on Tenmon waiting to see who would be bold enough to pick that of all the wagons considering how thorough Tenmon was in explaining himself, and here we go, someone actually bit.
I'm all ears now =3

In the meantime,
Lelouch and Isaac both make really good cases against each other, and personally? I want to keep them both around. Maybe it's because Isaac makes some really compelling points, or maybe it's Lelouch's flair, I just see value in keeping them around.
That only leaves one wagon, but I'm not too convinced about that one, and I still am bothered by Yuuki enough to:

Vote Lynch: Yuuki

And yes, I realize this is an extra wagon, and I am perfectly fine dropping this one in favor of voting Weevil. For now I will refuse on voting Isaac or Lelouch unless a more compelling argument comes up for either of them that tips the balance towards one side

Yuuki: you mention that I ignored your observations. Which ones? The ones where you said you/we couldn't figure anything out, or the ones that were a direct response to someone else where you briefly answer a question or agree/disagree?

Also, note that my main issue with you remains the same... even if Sakuragi was scummier in his inactivity, even with Kakashi still being for the most part a non-participant and Weevil making extremely brief posts... NONE of them, based on what I have seen, have been so keen and open to express lack of knowledge or inability to do anything.
And on one of your responses to Dandy you even thank him for enlightening you (I think it was Dandy, might have to re-verify) and showing you that there was indeed something to look at... but then you dont elaborate any unique view or points from this.

Note that I am perfectly fine being proved wrong on this perception, so please do so. Do what Sakuragi didnt and prove that my perception is misguided.

In the meantime, I look forward to seeing a better explanation from Astro Boy about that vote =3
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Astro Boy
Member Avatar
Astro Boy
Mimi
Oct 28 2016, 12:26 AM
Nope, sorry

Unvote

Astro Boy: Time to explain your vote a bit more. Kept my vote on Tenmon waiting to see who would be bold enough to pick that of all the wagons considering how thorough Tenmon was in explaining himself, and here we go, someone actually bit.
I'm all ears now =3
Well This makes me change my opionion of you, I think you caught yourself in a trap. I was suspicious of Tenma because as I said he felt like Mafia playing a convincing game of town so I decided to use one of my night abilities. I guess would appreciate it if the faith healer targets me since I just claimed. 100% fact: I investigated Dr. Tenma and got a mafia result. I am not risking this being twisted around in some way that you guys direct us towards another townie lynch.

Mimi
Oct 28 2016, 12:26 AM
In the meantime,
Lelouch and Isaac both make really good cases against each other, and personally? I want to keep them both around. Maybe it's because Isaac makes some really compelling points, or maybe it's Lelouch's flair, I just see value in keeping them around.
That only leaves one wagon, but I'm not too convinced about that one, and I still am bothered by Yuuki enough to:

Vote Lynch: Yuuki

And yes, I realize this is an extra wagon, and I am perfectly fine dropping this one in favor of voting Weevil. For now I will refuse on voting Isaac or Lelouch unless a more compelling argument comes up for either of them that tips the balance towards one side

Yuuki: you mention that I ignored your observations. Which ones? The ones where you said you/we couldn't figure anything out, or the ones that were a direct response to someone else where you briefly answer a question or agree/disagree?

Also, note that my main issue with you remains the same... even if Sakuragi was scummier in his inactivity, even with Kakashi still being for the most part a non-participant and Weevil making extremely brief posts... NONE of them, based on what I have seen, have been so keen and open to express lack of knowledge or inability to do anything.
And on one of your responses to Dandy you even thank him for enlightening you (I think it was Dandy, might have to re-verify) and showing you that there was indeed something to look at... but then you dont elaborate any unique view or points from this.

Note that I am perfectly fine being proved wrong on this perception, so please do so. Do what Sakuragi didnt and prove that my perception is misguided.

In the meantime, I look forward to seeing a better explanation from Astro Boy about that vote =3
Starting an extra wagon on an "easy" target once I put a vote onto Tenma and saying you would switch to weevil another player that is easy to explain a possible "mistake" if he flipped townie because of his poor playing really makes it hard for me to trust you.



Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Astro Boy
Member Avatar
Astro Boy
Key points:
I investigated Tenma he is mafia
I would be thankful if the faith healer targets me since I do still have a couple one shot abilities left and if luck is on our side a failed mafia attempt on me would give us proof of a second mafia

I hope even our most lazy of readers can grasp this.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Astro Boy
Member Avatar
Astro Boy
Your move mafia. Will you cut your losses since I already used up my most useful power? Or will you gamble on the 50% and try to take me down as revenge?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Mimi
Member Avatar
Digimon
You seriously think that me finding your random vote without substance scummy is a trap, really? Any logical individual would have called out that vote, it came about extremely nonsensically and out of nowhere.

But hey, things get interesting. On the possibility that you are being honest, this is a really good find given Tenmon's clear abilities as a townie and one that could give us the edge.
And then there's the possibility of you being scum who was caught being hasty, deciding to use the opportunity to throw a good townie to the bus, and figuring that while doing that you might as well throw dirt at another townie. So, with that in mind.

You need to explain yourself further. How do my actions make it hard for you to trust me?
I made it clear I dont trust Yuuki several hours ago, and it follows that if Im finally able to dismiss my Tenmon vote that I would want to vote pressure Yuuki into forming a tighter defense for himself.
It also follows that I would prefer actually having a lynch to not having a lynch at all, something consistent with my opinion since the game started. With that in mind, it is a transparency move to establish that while I believe in my wagon I am not stubborn enough to stick to it at the cost of us failing to achieve a lynch today.

And then, how is Yuuki an easy target? please define that for the group. I think Yuuki has expressed already, as in during the post he made while I was typing, that he is capable of defending himself. So I disagree with that, and would see other players as far easier targets.

Basically, claiming and then pointing fingers without actually elaborating why the individual you are pointing to is now suddenly untrustworthy is not enough to convince me you arent completely full of it. It is further nonsensical when you suddenly begin pointing fingers at the person who just called you out for making a questionable wagon choice without any development or elaboration whatsoever.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Pariston Hill
Member Avatar
Hunter x Hunter
With 10 players left, it takes 6 to lynch.

Isaac Dian (1): Lelouch vi Britannia
Lelouch vi Britannia (1): Isaac Dian
Edward Weevil (1): Dr. Tenma
Dr. Tenma (1): Astro Boy
Yuuki Rito (1): Mimi

Not Voting (5): Claire Stanfield, Edward Weevil, Kakashi Hatake, Yoshikage Kira, Yuuki Rito

You have 21 hours left in the Day.
Edited by Hinata Hyuga, Oct 28 2016, 03:09 AM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Lelouch vi Britannia
Member Avatar
Code Geass
Nooooo! After all that, Isaac will have to live another day!

Unvote

Vote Lynch: Dr. Tenma
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Lelouch vi Britannia
Member Avatar
Code Geass
@Astroboy I believe your claim but I feel you are misguided about Mimi. Without the claim, your vote on Tenma didn't have much proof, and certainly looked scummy.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · The Surface of Rakuen · Next Topic »
Locked Topic