Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]

Add Reply
  • Pages:
  • 1
  • 3
One World Edgic
Topic Started: Apr 15 2017, 01:07:31 AM (562 Views)
Lucy
Member Avatar

EDGIC Form Link

Please complete the above link prior to deadline to participate in EDGIC ratings this game. Please also share your rationale for reasoning in this thread. You may use either traditional edgic or the gamestyle analysis format in the poll. Someone will tabulate results and post the aggregate rating for each episode.

EDGIC is basically a rating system that is used to analyze patterns of how players are portrayed to see if winners can be determined from earlier in the game. It's using narratives and editing in a logical way based on many winning stereotypes.

Links of past EDGIC threads below:

Bad Edgic (School)
Nexus Edgic (Nexus)
Medical EDGICuation (Medevac)
Medgic Kingdom (MK)
LoL Edgic (LoL)
Monica Lewedgic (2016)
Affirmative Action Edgic (2016)
Eon Edgic (Eon)
Whitnedgic (BotB)
Eminedgic (BotB)

EDGIC description


Gamestyle Analysis (alternative system) description
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Lucy
Member Avatar

Anyone else going to do edgic this season? I'm going to post some ratings tonight. Poll is up and available for everyone too.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Nick
Member Avatar

I'll participate in a form edgic
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Lucy
Member Avatar

https://goo.gl/forms/ohMRINY7sLYUcPaI3 for those interested
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Lucy
Member Avatar

Posted Image

Posted Image

Clarence - went for captainship, but has mostly squandered those opportunities. Half of that is real-life, but he also needs to take more leadership. He's safe for the meanwhile, but if things get worse, he could be in trouble. I think he's doing enough to get by, and of course it's still too early to see if it has an impact later. But mostly, no one knows Clarence, and that's not a great thing either.

Courtney - Has stepped back and let the two main girls run their mouths. Courtney is playing a strong, typical game, and she's fallen into the right place and the right time. She's using the moments away from Katie/Sierra to bad talk them and she was entirely right to jump to Tasha's defense. And in a place like this, she's using these moments aggressively. However, Jaclyn is going to see that and that's putting a hamper on Courtney's play. But for right now, it's smart. But I'm not sure Courtney can still play the same way the entire game.

Cydney - Cydney is playing along with most everyone and is trying to position herself rightly, but has mostly just been at the wrong place most of the time. However, no one's thinking badly of Cydney, and no one's really adding her to the majority either. It's all fine play for now and Cydney is just being well-liked right now, and that's a great strategy for the long-run. If Cydney thinks that this is not being around much, I can't wait to see what she can do if she's truly around then.

Eddie - Everyone loves Eddie. Episode 1 this is great. Episode 4 this won't be. I hope Eddie learns how to pace himself, especially when he's not trying to take the reigns in his relationships.

Frosti - He's worried he's out of the loop, but no one's targeting him either. And you don't really need to be in the majority alliance with these guys. Frosti's playing it fairly safe, and he's doing well. But I think next episode, he's going to have to be a bit more aggressive in finding someone he can trust and rely on down the road.

Jaclyn - not a UTRus rating, but an OTTN for just being a cariacature of something she's not. There are amazing snippets of strong strategy though that are going to get Jaclyn far. Pleasantly surprised with the play here.

Jimmy - IDK. One moment he's gone, the next he's telling everyone he's not going to put in the effort to bond and read their words. One moment he's telling everyone he's a team player and is for the team, and then he's also dividing the team and attacking a figurehead. He was honestly safe before TC, but he's bombing it because he thinks he's on the his last leg. And the person who was really on his last leg (Penner) isn't trying to take advantage of all this.

John - he's trying to be strategic and make his own plans, but it's a bit slow to my taste. However, he's reaitonalizing everything in a great way and that it is moving toward his power development structure.

Julia - Everyone likes Julia, and she's just out of the loop. However, she's picking up on exactly what she needs to pick up on. She just needs to make sure she can be effective in moving things around to get where she needs to get.

Katie - too much a tribal leader. Cool it down.

Kenny - Kenny is a great choice because he's playing this game as a numbers game and not an emotions game. Without PMs, this is entirely possible, but he's gotta speak to his audience, and that definitely fell on deaf ears with Neal. But if he can keep around the people he needs, he could be in a great position moving forward.

Neal - Not really standing out. Just there and under the radar.

Penner - Not taking advantage of the small moments where he can shine. He thinks he's just following the crowd, when he needs to know that he's also on the chopping block and needs to be more aggressive. He's charismatic, and he's doing the best he can to respond and react to the snails thing when it shouldn't have happened in the first place.

Sean - Great intuition and he managed to help arrange so that he gets the message in the bottle. It might be more of a hassle though, especially since he was a target at some point this episode.

Sierra - over the top for sure. Just needs to calm it.

Stephanie - playing it so right here. Subtly offing off people, slowly getting others to enjoy her personality. Just the right balance here, and the theme of this game is balance.

Sundra - Does not really know how much trouble she's in. She's going to need a few immunities and will need someone to mess up even more to get the target off her back. Just not sure it's feasible anymore though.

T-Bird - Playing it safe, while also being helpful to others. Gotta keep it that way and she can go far.

Tasha - Played that Water thing well. Is playing a good foundation right now especially with Courtney, but will need to work on relationshiops next round as well.

I hope that explains my ratings.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Ken
Member Avatar

I'll probably start edgicing in a few eps when I'm not on gaycation/swamped at work.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Scot
Member Avatar

Scot's official edgic:

Posted Image
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Lucy
Member Avatar

Alright, here's episode 1 composite ratings now that task day is over. Please try to get your ratings in by end of task day so we can compile in due time.

Posted Image
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Lucy
Member Avatar

Don't forget to submit episode 2 edgic https://goo.gl/forms/ohMRINY7sLYUcPaI3
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Lucy
Member Avatar

I was the only one so I'll post mine from ep2 tonight. Hoping for more responses in episode3
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
ZetaBoards - Free Forum Hosting
Create your own social network with a free forum.
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · SPECS! · Next Topic »
Add Reply
  • Pages:
  • 1
  • 3