Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]

Add Reply
  • Pages:
  • 1
  • 3
One World Edgic
Topic Started: Apr 15 2017, 01:07:31 AM (563 Views)
Lucy
Member Avatar

EDGIC Form Link

Please complete the above link prior to deadline to participate in EDGIC ratings this game. Please also share your rationale for reasoning in this thread. You may use either traditional edgic or the gamestyle analysis format in the poll. Someone will tabulate results and post the aggregate rating for each episode.

EDGIC is basically a rating system that is used to analyze patterns of how players are portrayed to see if winners can be determined from earlier in the game. It's using narratives and editing in a logical way based on many winning stereotypes.

Links of past EDGIC threads below:

Bad Edgic (School)
Nexus Edgic (Nexus)
Medical EDGICuation (Medevac)
Medgic Kingdom (MK)
LoL Edgic (LoL)
Monica Lewedgic (2016)
Affirmative Action Edgic (2016)
Eon Edgic (Eon)
Whitnedgic (BotB)
Eminedgic (BotB)

EDGIC description


Gamestyle Analysis (alternative system) description
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Replies:
Gary
Member Avatar

also poor jimmy getting a utrn1 in his damn first boot episode. i feel for the guy.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Scot
Member Avatar

Merge edgic:

Posted Image
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Stacy
Member Avatar
Empking's Alt's Alt
what does the orange signify?
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Scot
Member Avatar

Slightly less N
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Lucy
Member Avatar

Ranking of most likely to make finals:

1. UTR - Clarence
-No one's really targetting Clarence and he's in a solid majority. He's seen as the least threatening of his group, and yet people seem to have strong trust in him (Eddie, Frosti, Julia, etc). I think we'd have to see his FTC to see his chances on winning, but I can see him getting there easily.

2. CPP - Eddie. Eddie made the move he needed to make this round. Instead of sitting around, Eddie seems to be pushing the moves. This is setting up a nice round. If Eddie had sat around and just been fake with Cydney, this TC would not be as this interesting and it'd be a clear Cydney boot. Instead Eddie is murking the waters and trying to keep Cydney as a meat shield while simultaneously trying to take down key members of the opposition alliance. This is a good move for Eddie because Cydney is a part of no alliance at the moment, whereas someone like John or Jaclyn going would definitely benefit Eddie. However, this may all be for naught, but at least Eddie is thinking strategically here.

3. MOR - Frosti. Frosti is still in the best position of anyone and can very likely win here. But Cydney's backstab plan is dropping the ranking. While Frosti is probably safe this round, Frosti's stock continues to drop because Penner is now anti-Frosti and the whole idol thing is going to continue to make others want to blindside him. Frosti without an idol is in a better position than one with. Frosti better solidify something within his alliance sooner than later - but at the same time his confessional is demonstrating a solo-plan. Frosti needs to have a partner in crime to make his boot list happen - and he doesn't have that yet.

4. UTR - Julia. Julia continues to be in a great position. Everyone wants to work with her, no one mentions her ever as a target. However, no one's going to want to go with her at the end. Julia can continue to play UTR status-quo for a few more rounds, but soon she's going to need to make a big move and I hope she does it with Penner - as I really like that pairing.

5. MOR - Penner. I think Penner knows that he's not a part of the core Dowdle 3.0. And Eddie is trying to push out Penner every chance he gets. However, I think Penner is better siutated to defend against that at this point. Penner needs to make his move next round though. This one doesn't really benefit him. If he does, and he can make a solid alliance, he's great. However, if Cydney's plan fails and Penner joins it, he could be in huge trouble in the next few rounds. Penner saying yes to Cydney so emphatically can become a huge obstacle unless Cydney is taken out now. I think it may be in Penner's best interests for Cydney to fail and to now implicate him. But I'd also like to see Penner initiate the move too and not just follow the key players.

6. CP - Kenny. Kenny is always thinking strategically, but he's also a bit aloof in that people aren't thinking of him as a F2 partner. This game is perfect for Kenny's strategy style. He's also doing so well right now and I think he will continue to make subtle moves to climb up the ladder one step at a time - but Kenny continues to be "elimination avoidant" in his overall orientation and he needs to start being more "alliance approaching" to see people more than just a number to him - if he can solidify a partner (Penner really should be this for Kenny) - he can run the tables. However, I see him being taken out quite soon which would be a shame.

7. UTR - T-Bird. Part of this may be my just missing out on key 3rd swap interactions, but it doesn't really sound like T-Bird has a key ally that would keep her from ever being voted out within her alliance. She is protected, but there's been a lot of talk (especially by Eddie) of her being expendable. I think Clarence is in her corner though - but Clarence doesn't have the voice to put his foot down and save her if that's the case. She's seen too much as a snake that she'll continue to be targetted and one of these times it's jjust going to happen by the counter alliance. This is a tribal where it's okay for her to follow the plan - and having Frosti with her is icing on the cake.

8. CPN - Jaclyn. Jaclyn is a lone wolf who's quickly regaining old allies. But the numbers right now are too solid. Jaclyn should be safe this round because they want her to flush an idol which she doesn't have. She's also working the crowd well by throwing Cydney under the bus to gain allies later. While she could just as easily try to be the pied piper of the minority, this is a format where it's very tough to do - so she might be better off by waiting just a bit and then she can attack, because she is a feisty guard dog.

9. UTRP - John. John is someone people like, but also John is doing nothing to survive long-term except surviving round by round. John might be brought to the end as a goat, but I think it's doubtful. John also needs to grab this game by the ball sack and just for it. John is likely out this round though.

10. OTTN - Cydney. No one wants Cydney in the end, but then again, the potential trainwreck of a FTC with her may be what someone is thinking of. Cydney is not giving up here, and it's to the detriment of the long-term game, but Cydney is right in putting it on the line for this tribal.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Gary
Member Avatar

I'd say Penner is UTR and Julia is MOR.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Gary
Member Avatar

Episode 5 Edgic


Does this look about right for Episode 5?
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Scot
Member Avatar

Finale EDGIC:

Posted Image
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
« Previous Topic · SPECS! · Next Topic »
Add Reply
  • Pages:
  • 1
  • 3