Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Locked Topic
  • Pages:
  • 1
  • 2
Night 1: The First Step; ... to the path of more carnage. And murder.
Topic Started: Sun 20 Nov 2016, 13:15:32 (219 Views)
DIO
Member Avatar
NOT MUDAdmin
The sun set and the long night has begun. The 3 of you retreat back to your evil lair with smiles on your faces. Killing the Godmin was not enough. You 3 are out for more games. And more blood.
Shou Tucker arranges the remaining body parts of the puny late god Light Yagami he managed to salvage for, erm, research purposes.
Pegasus can't stop sparkling.
Mari Kurihara wrinkles her nose at disgust at the repulsiveness of the 2 men. Carefully, she opens the little black notebook they seized from the fallen God, and readies her pen...

This is your Night 1 thread. You have 24 hours to plot the demise of one of those hapless fools. Choose the killer and the victim here; you must all agree on both of them, and each of you should post both names in bold.

Oh, and unfortunately, you can't kill me. Nor Jack, though I agree that the offer is pretty tempting. DIO snickers.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Replies:
Shou Tucker
Member Avatar
Fullmetal Alchemist
Mari Kurihara
Sun 20 Nov 2016, 15:58:09
Shou Tucker
Sun 20 Nov 2016, 13:20:50

a) We need to work out what time we can all be online at the same time going forward. Being well coordinated is what will make or break us (aside from shitty luck being or doom since you guys picked the vigilante and he could kill us)
Sowy :$

Regarding my availability, I´ll always be able to check the game on the phone every now and then, so I can always answer something if needed.
On the computer, mostly between 8PM and midnight GMT. I´ll probably have higher activity during these hours. Right now It´s 10 minutes away from 8PM GMT in case anyone is confused regarding time zones.

Ok so if I am reading this right Mari is about 5 hours ahead of me timezone-wise (assuming you are in the GMT timezone). Would the best time for our night2 council of carnage be 10pm/22:00 GMT? That gives me pleanty of time to get home from work (5pm) while not being too late for you.


Mari Kurihara
Sun 20 Nov 2016, 15:58:09
I also envisioned the idea of not killing someone in one of the nights for one of us to claim JK, but I don´t think we should do it right now.
Also, when all things considered, there´s only on role of the ones we picked that doesn´t have a "visible effect", the tracker, so if this guy gets found, we can´t claim this at all.
I agree that the no kill should probably wait. it might also cause someone to slip up and reveal they have a role if they doubt the existance of a JK.

Mari Kurihara
Sun 20 Nov 2016, 15:58:09
I made this "activity ranking list" which I pretty much do every game. It´s a subjective mix between number of posts, opinions stated and impression left on me:

Activity rankings:
- Shou
- Pegasus, Switch
- Sakura, Mari
- Akainu, Mitsugi
- Shiina
- Jimbei, Stain
- Kei
- Alpha

Yup, we´re all on the upper tiers, which can be bad in terms of gathering attention from the tracker and Vig, but good in terms of controlling the discussion of the game our way.
Tidy lists <3 I am a bit nervous about being so active since the Vig could be impulsive haha.

Mari Kurihara
Sun 20 Nov 2016, 15:58:09
So who do you guys prefer killing? I kind of want to think that one of the power roles would be in someone mid ranking. Shiina, Akainu or Mitsugi would be good choices.
Sakura seems very confrontational for someone possessing a role. Switch is clearly trying to individually get information out of people instead of approaching the group as a whole. He may be a Vig trying to make up his mind about possible targets, even though I doubt he will shoot tonight.
I fear that Switch is the tracker/vig since he was worried about the role discussion and claimed that it was "not helpful" so unless you guys have a better idea I figure we take the risk of hitting someone who confronted me on the chance he is the Vig.

Akainu, Mitsugi, Shiina and Tsukishima Kei are all other people that I think are possible power users. Akainu slightly less. I am against killing Sakura because she seems to fit my style of scum-hunting and I think I could "buddy up" with her.

Maximillion Pegasus
Sun 20 Nov 2016, 16:29:05
Scheduling: For Day 2 I am free a lot. Even when I am not free I can check my phone and give short answers if needed.
Night Actions: Mari would be the best choice for a kill as she is the least likely to get tracked. I am a potential target for both tracker and vig, Shou is a potential tracker target. A vig would have to be crazy bold to target me though, a bit too early. Should they decide to kill tonight then Alpha would be my best bet as he had absolutely nothing to offer town.
Other stuff: The jailkeeper confusion was legitimate, but we should be able to steer it towards a narrative where if I was the mafia I would have known.

Shou is on point saying that we need to continue to be the best scum hunters possible as townies. Going back over my own posts, Mari you are likely to be one of my main targets. If only because I called you out and I don't want to be seen as backing off too easily. Likewise I don't expect Shou to let off on me.

Of the players out there I see Shiina as most likely having a power role, vig or tracker. The innocent child I suspect will be as active and confrontational as possible, since they have no fear of being lynched, Switch and Sakura are both strong possibilities. I'd much rather try to take out tracker or vig though, so I would shy away from killing them right now.
I would prefer Switch over Shiina if only because Shiina is less confrontational which makes me feel they would hesitate more in shooting. The only hard part about "suspecting" you is that I have to filter out the fact that I am looking at you from the bias of knowing you are mafia haha.

Mari Kurihara
Sun 20 Nov 2016, 16:57:06
I´m also looking at both Shiina and Mitsugi. They are both pretty concise and straight to the point. Not causing a lot of waves but still participant enough.
Other than them, I wonder if Akainu is trying to look naive regarding the game rules in order not to be taken as a threat.
If Akainu is who I think he is we should leave him alive until night 2/3/4 so he hopefully cause chaos for us.

Mari Kurihara
Sun 20 Nov 2016, 16:57:06
I´m fine with being confronted by you, just remember two things:
1- If you are making me your target, don´t be afraid to cast a vote on me if needed. After all, if you insist on how suspicious I am but refuse to take a step forward, people might accuse you of faking your suspicion.
2- Always try to have a second suspect, so in case things get bad you can back off from me with a solid justification.

Other than this, if I get tracked and that guy shows himself, then don´t be afraid of being part of the wagon.

@Shou: How likely do you believe it is for the vigilante to have been active during this first day?
Noted. I will avenge you if you get tracked though.

Honestly I think the Vigilante was active if I was the vigilante I would not want to risk having the town turn against me for being un-helpful.

My top suspects for Vig are Switch and Stain I think Tsukishima Kei has a fairly high chance of being the tracker or the vig and a slight chance of being the child.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Shou Tucker
Member Avatar
Fullmetal Alchemist
Vote Kill: Switch
Vote Killer: Mari Kurihara

if you guys want to do something else I am open just figured I would place my vote for now. Will be back once I eat dinner and stuff.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Mari Kurihara
Member Avatar
Prison School
I´m only hesitant about killing Switch for three reasons.
One, like Pegasus said, it would be weird for the Vig/Tracker to be so active in D2. The child is more likely to do this.
Two, Switch has a confrontational style bound to gather attention and possible distract some townies from us.
Three, if the Trackers or any other roles like doctors and cops are usually more likely to target active players to see to what degree they can trust them, and the three of us are fairly active, eliminating Switch would give the tracker a bigger chance to hit one of us due to our activity.

Also, the power roles usually try to blend in the crowd. He basically individual questioned 1/3 of the players on D1.

I´m fine with killing him, but I would prefer one of mid tier players.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Shou Tucker
Member Avatar
Fullmetal Alchemist
Although Switch could possibly distract from us I feel like the possibility of him causing us a headache instead is worth not taking the chance. Also since he is confrontational I think if he is the Vig he is more likely to shoot us than someone else would be. I honestly think that his refusal to talk about powers greatly increases the chance that he has either Tracker/Vig (since we know he is not mafia)

Stain or Kei would be my other preferences. If I am wrong about the "not-talking about roles" connection for Switch I will calmly follow your lead on who to kill from now on (while still providing my opinion of course) but as of now my opinion on how badly people rank on the "need to get killed" list is:

1. Switch
2. Kei
3. Mitsugi/Stain
4. Shiina.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Mari Kurihara
Member Avatar
Prison School
K, I´m fine with the kill on Switch.
Let me just see if Pegasus has anything to say before casting a vote on that.

Regarding other stuff, if a wagon starts on someone that´s not one of us, I think one person should try to stay out of it. If another takes the responsability to hammer, it could also be seen as a position in which a mafia wouldn´t want to see himself in.

Not sure what else we can discuss. I kind of trust everyone to know what to do.
There still isn´t anyone that as done something suspicious enough to warrant us ganging on him without looking suspicious, so I don´t think we should set targets for today.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Shou Tucker
Member Avatar
Fullmetal Alchemist
Mari Kurihara
Sun 20 Nov 2016, 22:46:57
K, I´m fine with the kill on Switch.
Let me just see if Pegasus has anything to say before casting a vote on that.

Regarding other stuff, if a wagon starts on someone that´s not one of us, I think one person should try to stay out of it. If another takes the responsability to hammer, it could also be seen as a position in which a mafia wouldn´t want to see himself in.

Not sure what else we can discuss. I kind of trust everyone to know what to do.
There still isn´t anyone that as done something suspicious enough to warrant us ganging on him without looking suspicious, so I don´t think we should set targets for today.
Noted.

like you said for now we can't really gang up on people I will just continue to "investigate" Pegasus, Akainu and Alpha for the time being (and anyone else who gives me reason to)

I am off to bed pretty soon but I will check this topic first thing tomorrow morning when I wake up incase I need to shift my vote to someone else if you guys decide on another target or whatever.

For the mean time lets all hope we don't have horrible luck and wake up dead. Speaking of: Hey mods what happens if the mafia killer targets the Vigilante at the same time the Vig tries to make a night kill? Does the mafia kill take priorty?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
DIO
Member Avatar
NOT MUDAdmin
Both of you shall perish together if you target each other.

DIO polishes his road roller.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Mari Kurihara
Member Avatar
Prison School
Like an Old West Duel.

Posted Image
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Maximillion Pegasus
Member Avatar
Yu-Gi-Oh!
Switch definitely isn't a preference, but I'm willing to go along with your level of confidence.

Vote Kill Switch
Vote Killer Mari Kurihara
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
DIO
Member Avatar
NOT MUDAdmin
You 3 remind me of a certain son of mine.

.... wait what am I talking about?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · They had it coming. · Next Topic »
Locked Topic
  • Pages:
  • 1
  • 2

Black Water created by tiptopolive of the Zetaboards Theme Zone