Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Add Reply
Night #5
Topic Started: Mar 25 2017, 06:10 PM (290 Views)
Paging Dr. Page
Member Avatar

At this point I'm thinking Helios or Wikey. I just wish their claims were stronger. Helios has only hinted and never followed up while Wikey dropped a really typical scum claim. Slight edge to Helios I think. Wikey was almost too sure that Mittens was scum yesterday
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Nurse Zersch
Member Avatar

I can understand your hesitation Dr. Page. Those would be the two that I would have suggested. It is a tough call between them. I know what you mean about Wikey seeming way too certain that Mittens was scum. But after reviewing his voting record I felt the same way, prior to catching him red handed.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Nurse Zersch
Member Avatar

Do we want to keep my track on Sock?

And if you were to pass, would it be way too obvious if I claimed to have tracked you to whomever it was that was an evil doctor, to get them lynched?
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Paging Dr. Page
Member Avatar

I mean...we COULD also just go for Primate to be safest

If Dylan is Town then they'll likely kill him over Primate tonight, cause if they kill Primate Dylan will just see them. So we'll at least have a day with Primate on our team..but he'd probably end up dying the next night unless Mafia is really certain they aren't in his sights

I guess worse case scenario with that is if they go for him tonight too, but if that's the case I'd still be able to recruit the next night if I survive the day

I'm kinda back and forth on this. #1 priority is a successful recruit and ideally it would be someone who can carry the torch til the end. That doesn't sound like Primate, he'll be taken out sooner rather than later surely. He's the safest recruit but a bad long term investment
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Paging Dr. Page
Member Avatar

Nurse Zersch
Mar 26 2017, 04:39 PM
Do we want to keep my track on Sock?

And if you were to pass, would it be way too obvious if I claimed to have tracked you to whomever it was that was an evil doctor, to get them lynched?
Yeah I'd keep it on Sock I think

I'd focus on doing what you can to survive. You won't necessarily need to get a mafia lynched tomorrow because if that team is wiped out you're gonna have a long road to go. Plus if you sell one out then the other will kill you in the night soon. A townie mislynch would be better for you than a successful scum lynch at this point I think
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Paging Dr. Page
Member Avatar

Unless the person is going after you hard or something and is a direct threat/nuisance to you. Then I'd chuck them under the bus
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Nurse Zersch
Member Avatar

This is truly a surgical situation.

I honestly feel like the remaining pool of potential recruits aren't good long term investments. With Helios/Wikey the same things that seem cryptic/sus about both of them would be easy enough reasons for scum or invested town to push for their lynch as possibly "scum" or even Cult leader candidates.

A Primate recruit, if he didn't die tonight and died tomorrow night, would make Nofo and/or (if alive) Dylan look compromised to the rest.

Then the others are just, well you said it best, a shot in the dark.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Nurse Zersch
Member Avatar

##Track Sock
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Paging Dr. Page
Member Avatar

I'm very conflicted. Either way I think I'm set on avoiding Spin/Lamps/Sock/Nofo/Dylan and probably Brian. That only leaves Primate/Wikey/Helios
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Nurse Zersch
Member Avatar

Primate is definitely the safest of the three, but could be snatched from our hospitaly hands tonight. And definitely would be the following night. They may be wondering just how he could 100% know Mittens was scum and prioritize him over Dylan tonight.

Helios has a resume that barely edges out Wikey in the credential department, but he has barely been a presence this game and I don't see that changing if we recruit him. I guess that could be a plus in his column, I'm not sure. His claim is funky at best, and sits right next to Spin for me in the "what even is this" department.

Wikey was barely a presence but has come out swinging and would likely continue swinging for the rest of the game. And this could/should look sus to people that he only really begins on the day that the Cult is revealed. There's also no denying that his claim is the perfect "don't touch me for the rest of the game" claim, and that tends to be a scummy thing to do.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · The Cult · Next Topic »
Add Reply