Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Add Reply
Lamps
Topic Started: Aug 19 2017, 11:03 PM (22 Views)
J.J.
Member Avatar
Lena Dupree
D1:

Lynched Vlady, meta'd with Vlady. Said Patrick is a good lynch.



D2:

Trying to catch up.

Quote:
 
Timmah @ 11/8/2017 6:54
THE GREAT DR @ 11/8/2017 0:50
Timmeh, suspects besides merc?


Timmah
 
I'm curious about Maddie, but it's entirely because of the way I'm reading the posts of a person or two. That's vague, but I'm not trying to pull a DS here.

Otherwise, I don't have anyone solidly read as town or scum. It's early, things will start to shake out.


Lamps
 
As in, that push against Maddie seems to come out of nowhere? I think anyone can see that unless I'm missing something.




This post from Lamps stands out, too, as it was after Zersch called Maddie out, lynched her, but before she was shot by Rose.

But then this:

Lamps
 
I'm most suspicious of Maddie right now fwiw but it's only because of that apparently vague not so vague reason.

Then Merc idk it's sus he survived coz we had a town BP flip, but on the other hand he looks like the mafia kill. So I'd say 50/10/40 maybe for town/GF/TP on him. I'm also curious if he knows why he survived.

Shadow visiting merc is something to keep in mind.

Town read uhm Rose for sure lol, maybe zersch too and that is it.


Said has more to read but no time to catch up.

Quotes a Dadd post and says it pings scumdar:

Quote:
 
Dadd @ 11/8/2017 16:56
THE GREAT DR @ 11/8/2017 10:54
DADD.

TOP TWO SUSPECTS.

STAT!!!


I was thinking you about 15 pages ago ... I think you posted something about "all these day kills running around" ... seemed like an odd phrase to say.

I guess Merc?

And on D1 I was sus about im317 for some reason ... i must read back.


Lamps
 
Imo Maddie looks like for sure scum while Shadow and Vlady could POTENTIALLY be town. And Farlig (and to a lesser extent Vic maybe) looks bad too I agree.

##lynch Maddie

Not sure how much I will be on from now on but will TRY.


Quotes Spin and says this post pings scumdar:

Spin
 
##Unlynch

Maddie as mafia roleblocker was definitely a surprise. Didn't see that coming. Good work Zersch.

So, unless Zersch is pulling the double-secret-probation-mafia-usurper-awesomesauce-team thing again, I think he's probably pretty good.

While I don't completely buy Shadow's note claim, it's got me questioning my vote for the minute. I wouldn't be opposed to a Vlady lynch, as he doesn't really play on the weekend, so if the plan was to leave him alive to force a claim, I doubt it'll come today or on D3.


Quote:
 
Ahoda said it best imo, lynching vlady makes the most sense and shadow can prove his role if that is his role.

##lynch vlady


(Nothing really looks off except calling suspicions on Maddie "vague" after Zersch's info, but not sure how to read it really)


D3:

Lamps
 
Just woke up and caught up but bit confused by all that's been said. I was hoping there'd be some more clarity.

Shadow looks bad and hasn't said a word, no one has said they received a note or anything, so that is trouble. Needs pressure.

Also someone must know almost for a fact that someone is mafia.

##lynch shadow


Lamps
 
I got vibes~ from dadd yesterday but hard to explain why.

Also this jamie-mittens fight thing looks uncomfortable, wouldn't surprise me if one of them is scum.


Asks Dadd for thoughts, questions Herm on having Shadow as town read.

Brian kills Herm.

Lamps
 
Well herm looked a little shady gotta say, but killing him over Shadow, really?


Points out Herm's first post of the day: "Hey, I don't think Vlady or Lamps are connected lol."

Quote:
 
So Shadow is either mafia killer or hex girl?


Talk with Farlig about why he's lynching Shadow, not basing it on what Shadow said about role block thing.

VOTE COUNT DAY 3

Quote:
 
Shadow (9/13): Lamps, Mittens, Primate, Curtis, Jamie, DR, im, Ahoda, Spin, Christian
Ahoda (5/13): Timmah, Brian, Mittens, Dadd, Shadow, DR
Jamie (0/13): Mittens, Shadow
Mittens (1/13): Vic
DS (0/13): Spin
Angi (0/13): Jamie
Im317 (0/13): Curtis
Herm (0/13): Brian

Shadow has been lynched.


(nothing really stands out on this day but Shadow was obvious lynch)


D4:

Post his I am Town statement.

Says he thinks DS blocked JJ and points to DS saying he blocked JJ's posts as evidence. says "He also had this post with doubts about Christian, Curtis, Ben, but I think the above post was a more obvious hint."

Quote:
 
##lynch JJ

For now. I'm not against an Ahoda lynch rly but there's not as strong evidence. Also between Jamie and Mittens I am leaning town on Mittens and scum on Jamie but that is merely gut based on their posts. Still think one of them is scum.

Feeling a bit better about Dadd since he had a good point abt something JJ said yesterday lol. And JJ is scum imo.


Back and forth with JJ about the DS post. Asks Vic if anything Buffy posted makes him thinks she's town after Vic posts this:

Vic
 
I'm pretty sure Buffy, Mittens, Rose and Zersch are town

Everyone else idk


Vic says just a gut feeling.

Asks if anyone has seen David.

Asks Angi if she and JJ are both scum after Angi says JJ must be town since she's still alive (since Angi's still alive).

As to Ahoda's posted targets:

Lamps
 
Well it's irrelevant in the sense that no one really needs to know. Ahoda is either doc or he is not, but further details on his role could make things easier for scum.

Imo it's one of two things (if he is telling the truth):
- he can protect the same person back to back
- he cannot but doesn't want scum to know who he cannot protect the coming night


Lamps
 
Timmah and Christian are like so under the radar


Lamps
 
I'm willing to switch my vote, but I cannot look past that DS post saying he has buffy blocked.


Vote count at that time:

VOTE COUNT DAY 4
 


Jamie (4/12): TiB, Ahoda, Mittens, Primate
Mittens (1/12): Sock
Dadd (1/12): JJ
Christian (1/12): Vic
Ahoda (1/12): Timmah, Curtis
JJ (1/12): Lamps


Likes JJ post saying "I could see Curtis, Christian or Ben being Mafia and could be why DS was silenced and/or killed."

Spin reveals that lie detector says Dadd is scum. Brian kills Dadd.

Lamps
 
Wow at all this.

Also ##unlynch

It may all be a stretch, idk, but yeah it makes sense if DS actually blocked one of his prime suspects instead.


Lamps
 
Jamie's claim is a nice claim for a mafia role cop.


Lamps
 
I'm torn between Christian and Jamie. Christian is typically this UTR when scum and Jamie's claim is fishyyyy. Hmmmm


Lamps
 
I'm more convinced of Christian being scum looking at his posts this game

##lynch Christian


Lamps
 
This whole random thing is hard to buy tbh, makes little sense.


VOTE COUNT DAY 4
 


Jamie (8/11): TiB, Ahoda, Primate, Ben, im317, Curtis, Christian, DR, Farlig, Mittens
Christian (6/11): Vic, JJ, DR, Ben, Lamps, Angi, Sock, Spin
Mittens (2/11): Jamie, Sock
Spin (0/11): Mittens
Vic (0/11): Christian
JJ (0/11): Lamps
Ahoda (0/11): Timmah
Dadd (0/11): JJ, Spin, Curtis, Ahoda

Jamie has been lynched.


(Post about DS blocking JJ seemed like a stretch but could have really thought that. Lynching Christian over Jamie when he said he didn't buy Jamie's claim seems weird, although he had been saying Christian seemed scummy earlier.)


D5:

Lamps
 
I am trying to catch up but I'm at work and have a very busy day. May not finish until much later. Anything crucial happened?

Right now I think Sock, Christian, Angi are dirty,in that order, but need to fully catch up.


re Christian's claim:

Lamps
 
Wow ok wow. That is a weird role since even visiting the right person doesn't do a whole lot except if a cop visits them afterwards.


Lamps
 
I think Ben and Sock are good lynches. David too but he's even a bigger question mark.

I feel better about Angi after catching up. Also have had IM pegged as town bcuz of something he said with regards to being bussed? Iirc? I don't think it's something scum would say but ofc it's possible.

I think we should be able to narrow this down.


Lamps
 
Idk what I have done that ppl get vibes and stuff from. I've been posting reads and been trying to scum hunt (when not busy like today) so i don't really know what ppl want me to say but i'm not scum.

##lynch Ben


Lamps
 
Alive (20/31)

1. Angi - clean
4. im317 - clean
5. Sock - dirty
6. Spin - clean
9. Lamps - scummy
10. Farlig - idk but leaning clean
11. Curtis - see farlig
13. Brian - clean
14. Christian - dead
16. Primate - possibly dirty
18. Ben - dirty
19. TiB - see farlig
20. Ahoda - dead
21. Timmah - dirty
22. Mittens - clean
26. JJ - clean?
28. DR - clean
29. Zersch - clean
30. Vic - clean
31. David - who?


Lamps
 
This looks easy to narrow down. 3 dirties makes 5 mafia in total. Add one or two unknowns and u get mafia sauce.


Mittens
 
So looking at the vote shifts..

I think the most interesting time period is from 1:20 to 2:47 where DR, Ben, and Lamps move on to Christian, while im317 moved on to Jamie, giving Christian a 5 votes to 4 lead over Jamie.


After that, DR moved back to Jamie (I'll want to check into the timing of this), but Ben and Lamps stayed on Christian until the end.

I'm good with pressure on either of those two based on this alone.


Lamps
 
I get the Christian vote looks bad esp when it was this close. I never had the opportunity to switch my vote (not sure if I would have but you stating I "stayed on Christian" is kinda eh yeah?). It was really a coin toss for me when I voted and both looked about equally bad. If you really think I was protecting Jamie there after being the first to bring him up days earlier then ok I'll be your sub for spin to tunnel on.


JJ
 
There has to be scum on that Jamie lynch.


Lamps
 
If there is, then it's primate imo. I believe in my list.


Lamps
 
I have not seen David lurking - but he could be the 15 Users Viewing (14 Members, 1 Guests):


Ben
 
I'm heading home now I'll ch ck back when I get home and eat something, but I'm not scum.


Lamps
 
Think of a good claim while driving.


VOTE COUNT DAY 5
 


Farlig (6/10): Timmah, Curtis, DR, JJ, Mittens, Spin
Ben (3/10): JJ, Lamps, Vic, im317, Angi
David (2/10): Spin, TiB
TiB (2/10): Sock, Primate
Sock (1/10): Ben, Mittens
Timmah (0/10): DR
Angi (0/10): TiB
Mittens (0/10): Sock, Spin
Curtis (0/10): JJ
Spin (0/10): Mittens
Christian (0/10): DR, Curtis

Farlig has been lynched.


(Looks good for the Ben lynch, especially since he was 2nd on it. clean/dirty list isn't that bad - things that stand out are listing angi/im317 as clean and sock as dirty)


D6:

Lamps
 
If anyone on that farlig train is scum then it's curtis imo and he's doing a damn good job blending in.


Lamps
 
I don't trust Primate at all. He had Ben in his top scum lists all the time yesterday but never voted him. Threw his vote away more or less. Also when my name was mentioned (same time when Ben's train was gaining steam iirc) he all of a sudden added my name to his suspects. Didn't like that, looked like he needed another option to stay away from a Ben vote.

I think scum sees me as a possible lynch instead of one of theirs as I have not claimed + was on Christian's train which made it look like I was trying to save Jamie.


Lamps
 
I need to update my dirt list, but I'd put Primate on dirty and Sock on possibly dirty since Ben voted him twice now. He's quite impossible to read.


In regard to Farlig train:
Lamps
 
Oh nvm Timmah is the dirty one there. Still not so sure about Curtis though :p


Lamps
 
Anyone helping the farlig lynch by throwing some shade his way and then not voting him looks just as bad imo. I know primate was one example.


In response to Rose asking how Lamps feels about a Timmah vote:
Lamps
 
No problem with that but I am more convinced that primate is dirty.


Questions TIB liking a post where Lamps talks about Ben being dead then says something about Ben needing to be shot.

Lamps
 
For a second I thought Primate was claiming "Brian's role" because of how he announced that Brian probably already shot Ben. Other than that uhm nope I have him on the dirt list.


Lamps
 
I keep seeing my name over and over, can we rly only play this game by claiming the shit out of it?


Primate
 
Tib and lamps for reasons discussed yesterday.

If there's another baddie on the lynch yesterday. I think it's jj.


Lamps
 
Why do you say "another baddie on the lynch yesterday"? Another?


Lamps Dirt List
 
1. Angi - leaning clean
4. im317 - clean
5. Sock - leaning dirty
6. Spin - clean
9. Lamps - unclaimed
11. Curtis - idk
13. Brian - clean
16. Primate - dirty
18. Ben - dead dirt
19. TiB - clean
21. Timmah - dirty
22. Mittens - clean
26. JJ - leaning clean
28. DR - clean
29. Zersch - clean
30. Vic - clean
31. David - leaning dirty simply because of the number of ppl I think are town

I believe in this list.


Agrees with Curtis that he wasn't around to switch off Ben vote D5:

Lamps
 
This is correct. Farlig was not even a lynch target even when I was around. But to be fair I would not have switched, since I believed in my list yesterday.


Lamps
 
Looking back at the prev day I noticed Primate was the first (yes? second?) to mention Ben at all, so probably clean actually.

I still think TIB is clean as well though.

I'm wondering, Primate, you did not softclaim Brian's role? Cuz that's all that I saw as far as a softclaim goes.


in response to JJ asking why Lamps has TIB as clean:
Quote:
 
It's partly vibes, but I also had the impression that he was on the verge of claiming something that he can prove.


in response to im317:
Quote:
 
I don't get this, but I'm not too familiar with the flavor so not sure if that explains. What makes you think those persons are town? Flavor? Also do you think they knew before Christian flipped that Christian was talking about them? ie. that they have something in their role write up or something.


Quote:
 
I wish I had 2 kills today. David would be a dead fish by now.


Quote:
 
You think Brian not town is actually an option?

I think Sock's claim is fishy since Nofo was already town BP protecting him for his first kill attempt.


Quote:
 
Oh now I see what you mean. Town day kill bullet proof being safe from town day killer. Yeah I didnt think of it that way but that doesn't make much sense, town bp roles are more designed to protect from mafia/SK kills?


Quote:
 
The one thing giving me pause is Ben voting Sock twice but that could be distancing?


Quote:
 
I am more for lynching Sock rn, since it's possible he is GF and immune to whatever kills.

##lynch sock


VOTE COUNT DAY 6
 


Sock (6/9): Ben JJ, Timmah, Curtis, Lamps, im317, Primate, Mittens
David (2/9): Spin, JJ
Lamps (1/9): DR
Timmah (0/9): JJ, Primate
Ben (0/9): Angi, Primate, Timmah

Sock has been lynched.


(doesn't look good for Sock lynch, other than that, clean/dirty list looks pretty reasonable)
Edited by J.J., Aug 20 2017, 07:31 PM.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
J.J.
Member Avatar
Lena Dupree
Conclusions:

D1: Nothing stands out
D2: Nothing really looks off except calling suspicions on Maddie "vague" after Zersch's info, but not sure how to read it really. Nothing to really say about Vlady lynch since it was the obvious lynch.
D3: Has vibes about Dadd, thinks one of Mittens or Jamie is scum. Otherwise, nothing really stands out and Shadow was obvious lynch.
D4: Votes JJ due to what he thinks is clue from DS, then unlynches thinking DS could have blocked one of his listed prime suspects. Torn between lynching Jamie & Christian. Thinks Jamie's claim is scummy. Lynches Christian. Posts again that Jamie's claim doesn't make sense. Doesn't look great for lynching Jamie over Christian, although did say he thought Christian looked scummy previously.
D5: Looks good for the Ben lynch, especially since he was 2nd on it. clean/dirty list isn't that bad - things that stand out are listing angi/im317 as clean and sock as dirty.
D6: Lynched Sock which obviously looks bad. Doesn't buy the BP aspect since Nofo was one-time BP. Also doesn't think protection from daykills make sense. Thinks Timmah looks bad of the people on Farlig lynch, but not sure about Curtis either. Thinks Primate looks dirty, in response to Rose asking how he feels about a Timmah lynch. Changes mind as he looked back at previous day and thinks Primate was first or second to mention Ben. Said if he had two kills David would be dead.
Edited by J.J., Aug 20 2017, 09:17 PM.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
« Previous Topic · Werecats Discussion · Next Topic »
Add Reply